He's prollyt 230 in that pic that was taken after he retired. He was measured at 74" for his fight with Mitchell. I will cite my sources tomorrow. If you have no sources, then we no where this discussion has gone.
74" might have been decent in Sullivan's day, but one thing is undeniable. He was a puncher, not a boxer and to be successful at 5'10" with a 74 reach, he would need to be reasonably athletic vs the top opponents 5-30 years after he retired. A good athlete in boxing has their own version of built in defense and counter punching. I like to hear Pollack ring in, he might know something we don't. For now the only thing I'm sold on is he had reasonably fast hands. While hand speed really decreases in the as a person hits the wrong side of 30, gyms are full of fat boys with fast hands. We have some today. If I can read a report when Sullivan was in the mid 1880's with fast hands, that would mean something.
“One thing is for certain and that is that neither Mace or Sayers ever encountered so hard or so quick a hitter as in John L Sullivan. It was this writers fortune to see the fight between Heenan and Morrissey and had Sullivan been on the boards that day it is my opinion that he could have whipped them both one after the other. Those who think that he is not a thoroughly scienced man are mistaken. He has a far better knowledge of the fistic art than either Heenan or Morrissey possessed. He is stronger than either and unquestionably he is the hardest hitter known to the records of the ring”. National Police Gazette “Sullivan showed one point of his science by quick movements of his head completely eluding on such occasions the heavy blows which were aimed by McDonald” Denver Tribune Republican “I have seldom seen a man who advances the truth which is that Sullivan is as clever as any man. His unquestioned ability as being the hardest hitter ever seen has caused overlooking of the fact that his blow is always planted where it will do the most good either on the jaw or jugular. The truth is that Sullivan is a careful scientific fighter”. Chicago Herald
Some of his own thoughts on the fistic arts: “The essentials of a good fighter are pluck skill endurance and a good head on his shoulders. A man fights with his head almost as much as he does with his fists. He must know where to send his blows so that they will do the most good. He must economize his strength and not score a hit just for the sake of scoring it. I endeavor to hit my man above the heart or under the chin or behind the ear. A man wears out pretty soon if one can keep hammering away at the region of the heart, a blow behind the ear will knock a man out quicker than a hundred on the cheek or any other portion of the face”. “Learn to strike straight and clean, swinging blows nearly always leave you open for your opponent. It is well to do your leading with the left reserving the right for any good openings. Wherever you hit your man with one hand let the other fist land in the same spot if possible”. “Always watch your opponent. Just as soon as you see him about to lead shoot your left into his face. The force of him coming towards you will increase the blow considerably”. John L Sullivan
I found a somewhat similar description in an old newspaper column: https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...-sullivans-training-regimen-and-diets.648801/
You are entitled to your opinion but that photo is a fact. He had short arms, period. Your source, whoever it is, will be exaggerating his physical attributes.
Read up on his bouts with Choynski and Fitzsimmons. They battered Jeffries mercilessly. He won his fights on sheer brute force and his ability to withstand shocking punishment. Nothing wrong with that; by all accounts he was incredibly strong. But he was no artful boxer. A brawler not a boxer. Why does that shock people? Is someone here going to report that he was the Ali of his day? The guy could crush opponents with his punches, that point is not arguable.
Photos are strange and he is a butterball in that photo which throws off relative dimensions. I will go by documented contemporary sources. His reach was longer than Marciano, Tyson, Frazier, Patterson and the same as Walcott.
janitor is right, you are not on the same page to reports of his fights, but it's not a thread to argue about Jeffries.
Jeffries had like 7 fights, Choysnki was in his prime. Jeffries says Choysnki was floored three times, Choynski ran. Jeffries first fight with Fitzsimmons was a pretty easy one for him. In the second fight, both men won two rounds, Fitz who did something to his gloves won two rounds cleanly, Jeffries came on in the 7th winning that round and finished him int he 8. I can see you have a lot to learn. Here's a detailed round by round report of Fitz vs Jeffries 1. By all means read it, and reply back if you think Jeffries was an oaf, and wasn't winning this fight. FIGHT BY ROUNDS<BR> <BR> CONEY ISLAND SPORTING CLUB (Ringside.) June 9 -- When time was called for the<BR> first round Bob dances as Jeffries feints. They break instantly, and Jeffries<BR> is short of a left jab for the head. Jeffries is short with a left again, but<BR> touches the wind and puts a left on the neck.<BR> <BR> Second round -- Jeffries misses a left for the head, and Bob rushes and puts a<BR> left on the neck and a right over the heart. Jeffries closes into a light<BR> clinch, then, crouching, pushes a left to the stomach, but his right swing<BR> only grazes Bob's shoulder. Jeffries rushes two lefts to the wind and then<BR> jabs the face twice with the left. Fitz swings a right to the shoulder.<BR> Jeffries shoots a straight left to the jaw and Bob goes down squarely. He is<BR> soon up and starts to rush, but his left and right drives for the head are<BR> neatly blocked.<BR> <BR> Third round -- A clinch to open. Fitzsimmons missed a left, and Jeffries comes<BR> back with a left on the nose, and the claret shows on Fitzsimmons' face. Bob<BR> plants a good right over the heart, and after an exchange of left-handers,<BR> Fitzsimmons pokes the left to the neck, and Jeffries comes back hard on<BR> Fitzsimmons' ribs with a left, and a right to the stomach. Jeffries jabs the<BR> left twice to the face. Jeffries puts a stiff one on the stomach with the left<BR> and repeats it a little later. Fitzsimmons hooks a left to the ear, and his<BR> right goes over Jeffries' head, and an instant later Jeffries ducks another<BR> one. Now Jeffries ducks into a stiff left, catching it on the mouth. The men<BR> were sparring at the bell.<BR> <BR> Fourth round -- Jeffries misses a left, but ducks Fitzsimmons' right swing.<BR> Fitzsimmons misseds a left for the stomach, and Jeffries puts a good right<BR> over the heart. His left for the wind is stopped, but he shoots a hard left to<BR> the neck. Fitzsimmons smiles and hooks a right to the ear: Jeffries planting a<BR> sledge-hammer right over the heart. Another miss of Fitzsimmons' right draws<BR> Jeffries' right to his ribs. Fitzsimmons puts a light left to the mouth and<BR> brings his right to the ear, and Jeffries ducks into a stiff left swing. He<BR> rushes Bob to the ropes, good footwork carrying Fitzsimmons out of danger.<BR> <BR> Fifth round -- Bob puts a left straight on the mouth and Jeffries misses a<BR> left for the head. Fitz cuts the eye with his right. Both miss lefts. Bob<BR> shoots a left to the bad eye and swings to the ear with the same glove. Bob<BR> puts a left straight on the mouth, and Jeffries misses a left for the head.<BR> Fitz cuts Jeffries' eye with his right. Both miss lefts. Bob shoots a left to<BR> the bad eye and swings to the ear with the same glove. Jeffries sends a left<BR> to the wind and a right to the ribs. Fitz rushes and puts a left on the neck,<BR> and Jeffries misses a savage left swing. Jeffries shoots a straight left to<BR> Fiz's mouth and Fitz tries a left for the solar plexus. Jeffries plants a left<BR> on the chin, then jabs the face with a short-arm left. Fitzsimmons misses two<BR> lefts, and Jeffries hooks the right, sending Bob to his knees. He is up in a<BR> jiffy, and Jeffries pushes a right on the ribs and a left on the nose, Bob<BR> replying with a light left on the head. At the close Jeffries jabs.<BR> Fitzsimmons gets a left on the stomach. Jeffries' work has pleased his<BR> friends, but Bob's friends feel as confident as ever.<BR> <BR> Sixth round -- Fitz was up and ready ten seconds before the gong. He swings a<BR> right to the back of Jeffries' ear, then jabs the latter's face with the left,<BR> Jeffries countering with his left on the mouth. Bob jabs a left to the chin,<BR> but misses a right, and Jeffries swings a left to the forehead. Jeffries ducks<BR> with a right hook on the ear. They swap left-facers and Bob misses a right<BR> swing, Jeffries smashing the wind with the right. Bob puts Jeffries across the<BR> ring.<BR> <BR> Seventh round -- Fitzsimmons runs Jeffries across the ring, but is short with<BR> the left, and Jeffries sends a hot left to the face. They come together,<BR> Jeffries' right slapping Bob's side, sounding like a drum. Jeffries barely<BR> touches the chin, Bob stopping handsomely. Jeffries clinches against the next<BR> two leads, but Bob puts a right on the ear. Jeffries answering with a right on<BR> the ribs. Fitzsimmons lands a light left on the neck, then a straight left to<BR> the mouth. Both miss lefts, then swap rights on the head. Fitzsimmons stops<BR> Jeffries' swing, and puts two lefts on the mouth and neck, cutting the mouth<BR> severely. Jeffries' left goes over the shoulder and Bob digs a right<BR> wickededly under the heart. The gong then sounds.<BR> <BR> Eighth round -- Jeffries' legs are worked upon vigorously by his attendant.<BR> Bob puts a left to the neck, but misses a right swing. Jeffries sends a left<BR> to the ribs. He missed a right swing. Jeffries put a left to the ribs, Bob<BR> putting a straight one on the mouth. Bob put a left to the neck, but misses a<BR> right swing. Bob misses a right, and Fitz jolts Jeffries with the left; then<BR> shoots to the mouth and follows again to the jaw. There are two clinches, and<BR> Jeffries shoves a right to the ribs, Fitz reaching the chin with his left.<BR> Fitz sent a straight left to the eye, Jeffries touching to the stomach with<BR> his left. Bob sent a left over Jeffries' shoulder, and Jeffries swings his<BR> left a foot over Bob's head. A straight left on the jaw sends Fitz reeling to<BR> the ropes. Out in the center he clinches, then swings a hard left to Jeffries'<BR> head. The bell rings.<BR> <BR> Ninth round -- Jeffries jabs a left on the mouth. Another left from Jeffries<BR> to the mouth, and then he hits to the neck. The men swap rights. Jeffries'<BR> left draws more blood from Bob's nose. Bob misses a right, and Jeffries puts a<BR> right on the ribs. Jeffries' left finds the chin and Jeffries pokes a left to<BR> the face. Bob comes back with a straight left on the mouth. Jeffries swings<BR> twice with the left on the head. Fitz hooks a left to the neck. They swap<BR> lefts on the head. Bob plants a left on the neck.<BR> <BR> Tenth round -- Jeff springs in and hugs Bob. After the break he pokes a left<BR> to Bob's chest, then a left to the jaw, Bob replying with a left on the eye.<BR> Fitz misses a left hook, ducking nicely Jeff's right, and is stopped by Bob's<BR> elbow. Bob puts a left on the cheek, Jeffries missing his answer. Fitz misses<BR> a left and a right swing, and Jeffries jabs a left to the mouth. Fitz crowds<BR> him to the corner. Jeffries shoots a straight to the jaw. Bob falls flat on<BR> his back and takes eight seconds to arise. When he gets up Jeffries swung a<BR> right to the neck, and again Bob is down. He gets up, but is sent to his knees<BR> by a left, when he arises he clinches and the bell is heard. Just as the bell<BR> sounds Fitz swings a wild left. Fitz is very groggy.<BR> <BR> Eleventh round -- Fitz was up briskly for this round. He misses a left for the<BR> head. Jeffries clinches. Fitz misses a right jab, Jeffries jolting the neck<BR> with a left. Fitz uses a left on the stomach and a right on the chest. Fitz<BR> misses a right, and Jeffries plants a right over the heart. Jeffries sent a<BR> straight left to the mouth, sending Bob's head back, but Bob is still there.<BR> He puts a left on the shoulder. Jeffries puts a right on the wind and a left<BR> to the eye. Two more lefts from Jeffries on Bob's head, then Jeffries jabs the<BR> left twice like lightning. Now two left swings go to the neck and jaw, and a<BR> right swing is sent to the point of the jaw and the Cornishman falls prone.<BR> <BR> He falls on his side and rolls over on his back. The referee counts 1, 2, 3,<BR> 4, 5, 6. Bob rolls over. Then 7, 8, 9, 10. Fitzsimmons is out, and Jeffries is<BR> champion of the world. The referee waves his hands to the seconds to carry<BR> Fitzsimmons to his corner. They lift him, still unconscious, and sit him in<BR> his chair. He revives rapidly.<BR> <BR> Meanwhile, a shouting, cheering crowd surrounds Jeffries in his corner. Fitz<BR> sits disconsolate in his chair, and the Californian crosses the ring and<BR> shakes hands. Jeffries leaves the ring in the center of a shouting, howling<BR> mob.<BR> <BR> It was a great fight, and was fought on its merits. It is another illustration<BR> that youth and strength are too big handicaps for age to encounter. Fitz left<BR> the platform a few moments after the battle.<BR> <BR>
Your version of the Choynski fight is laughable. It was a 20 round DRAW. Jeffries was quoted as saying Choynski hit him the hardest he ever got hit. In fact "During that bout, Choynski hit Jeffries with a right hand so powerful that the punch drove one of Jeffries' teeth into his lip. The tooth was lodged so deeply that one of Jeffries' cornermen was forced to cut it out with a knife between rounds." The excuse that Jeff had only 7 fights is just that...an excuse for a brawler who couldn't take out a much better, faster boxer. Here's another version of the first Fitz fight, now you can learn. Article can't be cut and pasted, but I've included it below. Fitz was at least 13 years older, some say much older. He was outweighed by 40 pounds. Fitz bloodied Jeffries from the 4th to the 8th round. Jeffries face was described as "a mess". He was being outboxed, because, well, as I've stated, he was a brawler and not a boxer. Sorry if this butt hurts you, but there it is. Jeffries finally landed a lucky punch, as described by observers, to win over a much better boxer who he outweighed by 40 pounds and who was AT LEAST 13 yrs older. Many felt the KO looked fake and was called a fix, but Fitz said it was a fair fight. https://www.boxingnewsonline.net/on...simmons-in-the-eighth-round-of-their-rematch/