Who would win if Mayweather Jr. fought the likes of Sugar Ray Robinson and Julio Cesar Chavez Sr?

Who would win if Mayweather Jr. fought the likes of Sugar Ray Robinson, Julio Cesar Chavez, Pernell Whitaker, Wilfredo Benitez and three of the Fab Four? (Obviously left Hagler out of the fab four here as he would have destroyed Floyd at 160.)

 

Floyd beats Chavez but loses to the rest.

 

He probably loses to them all. I don’t think he’d like fighting Benitez or Whitaker. He never seemed to want to fight defensive fighters.

Chavez beats him close but clear, Duran would probably dominate him (I don’t think he had the offense to do much with Duran), Leonard is a little closer but he doesn’t come close to winning. Hearns is the nightmare for him. Would get iced within six or get dominated on points by wide decision.

 

Loses a relatively close decision to Robinson. Outscores Chavez by a decent margin the vast majority of the time in my opinion. 50:50 against Whitaker at 135 lb, but I'd take Floyd over Pernell at 147. I'd favour him over Benitez at 140, think it's a pick'em at 147, and would give a small edge to Benitez at 154. Narrow underdog against Duran at 135, narrow favourite over him at 147. Loses clear decisions to Leonard and Hearns at both 147 and 154 but isn't disgraced against either.

 

Floyd would probably try to walk Benetiz down....not sure he’d be successful at it ....And why am I not sure ? Because he never fought a “ Slick “ fighter

 

I'll do all of them at 147
Sugar Ray - Floyd loses a wide UD
JCC - Floyd dominates, wins a wide UD
Pernell Whittaker - Floyd loses a SD, Pernell pre-1996 is more active
Wilfred Benitez - Floyd wins a close but clear UD
Ray Leonard - Leonard wins a UD
Roberto Duran - 50/50, Floyd's more consistent but his best night at 47 is nowhere near Duran's
Tommy Hearns - There is a genuine chance of a knockout here but mostly Hearns by wide UD

 

I think he loses to Robinson but beats Chavez.

 

Not at 135.

 

Loses to Robinson by competitive UD

Beats Chavez by decisive UD

Loses to Benitez by SD

Beats Whittaker by controversial SD

Loses to Leonard by UD

Loses to Hearns by Pretty Wide UD or late TKO

Loses to Duran by MD (though I think he'd win a rematch)

 

Floyd "dominate" Chavez? No.

 

At 147, I see him being a relatively comfortable night for Floyd.
Why do you believe otherwise?

 

Chavez beats Floyd as well. Floyd had major trouble twice with Castillo who is a poor man's Chavez. Julio by UD for sure

 

the only thing that's 50/50 with Duran is if Floyd stays upright

 

Agree with every prediction.

 

I think he might beat Benitez but he'd lose to the rest.