Is Carl Froch amongst the top ten SMW fighters of all time?

well whatever, froch IS a top 10 Super middle.

in my humble opinion.

There are also so many forgotten european Super middle champs that could possibly scratch into the top 10

 

straightforward question tbf

 

Omitting Roy and Toney opens up a further 2 spaces.

If they weren’t there he’d have a place.

With those 2 included, it gets tighter, especially if you’re rating on H2H ability. But it’s irrelevant. Because without Roy and Toney on your list, the list isn’t credible.

Roy and Toney are 2 of the greatest SMW’s of all time.

 

Shut up you fool.

You have destroyed the credibility of your own thread by imposing ridiculous restrictions upon yourself.

You’ve just removed Toney as well as Roy based on what I’ve said.

You’re an embarrassment.

 

man just say if you think froch is a top 10 super middle lol

 

How can I give Froch a ranking on a list that has 2 of the best fighters removed?

It’s not even a credible list if you don’t have Roy and Toney on it.

Yes, if they’re gone, of course there’s room for him. But what’s the point in putting him there?

 

Never considered how much the top 10 SMWs are dominated by British/Europeans before

 

I’ve already answered you, genius.

If they’re not there, that frees up two further spaces. So of course he makes the list. But a list without Roy and Toney is completely pointless.

Removing Roy was dumb, but now you’ve removed Toney because you’ve got to go away and assess whether or not you think he was a better MW.

You have destroyed your OWN thread.