Who really won Floyd Mayweather vs Jose Luis Castillo 1

You didnt see the fight without your Floyd fan glasses.
IMO he lost thats all..
I saw the fight three times

 

So pbf didn't win but 1 round for the rest of the fight after being up 4-2 ? You're full of **** like all the people who say pbf clearly lost to jlc.

 

When I watched this fight i was in jr. High and was a big mayweather fan, but I remember agreeing with harold lederman's scorecard.

 

Getting dropped implies a knockdown.

Judah scored a knockdown on him. It just wasn't called.

 

It was close. Mayweather probably won 3 of the first 4 rounds but Castillo won most of the rest and probably did enough to shade it by a point or so.

 

I never said I support Floyd.

I'm just confused as to why you keep bringing up random topics on a thread about a fight between Floyd and Castillo.

 

Funny isnt it Everyone who disagrees with you about IV Kid Clenelo etc are immediately labelled HATERS!! Its you worshippers of Cowardly cheaters that should be haters of honest legitimate champions. The vast majority of fans regard both your heroes as CHEATERS!! because even the State Commissions are in on it Castillo won fight1 Fight2 could have gone either way
In a way youre right though I do DETEST the cowardly cheats & those that back them to ensure they cannot lose. Name me one close fight, & he's had many, that didnt go IVKids way in a lop sided decision win for him in Vegas?????? You cannot there isnt a single one

 

Exactly my friend you summed him up spot on

 

Thats cause he's always running away or holding like a limpet LOL He should have been DQ'd IMMEDIATELY when Roger entered the ring & attacked Judah anyway anyone else would have

 

I just brought up the difference Pac really had a torn rotator cuff going in against Floyd he had surgery immediately afterwards the surgeon commented he must have been in severe pain throughout the fight. Floyd fans claimed he said swimming in sea cured it ROFLMAO
Whereas Floyd CLAIMED after the fight he had the same injury. NO SURGERY was ever performed I guess Ellerbe's consoling & caressing him. That was just an excuse for getting his ass BEAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Yeah but Pac isn't part of this thread at all.

It's purely about Floyd and Castillo, nothing else.

 

Right.. Then he said Floyd was the cash cow when he only made 2 million that fight.. He didn't start making money like that until years later.. He think today's Floyd is what he was his whole career when he knows it's not facts.. We're talking about one fight and he bringing up Canelo and the NSAC like Arum wasn't his promoter...lol

 

Personally I cited both fights in line with the judges score, had the first fight 8-4ish thought Mayweather won the first 5/6 rounds and while Castillo closed strong thought Mayweather did enough early.

I personally had the second fight closer 7-5 in a super tight fight, and always thought that was the 50/50 bout. Honestly at the end of fight I, I was surprised at punch stats but it is what it is.

 

I still haven't seen this fight.


This is one fight which if he loses could perhaps sway my opinion that he is the best fighter ever. He never declined. He never fell out of his prime. He really got hit hard or hit period. He fought and beat the best and most never really recovered. Their careers were never the same bar one or two.

Mosely hit him with two rockets yet he came back from those. He had a great chin. ODLH lost by two rounds. Oscar was his own worst enemy he even said it himself.

Oscar, if he kept his head on straight wouldn't have tasted defeat until PAC and B-Hop in a perfect world.

In, a perfect world.

 

I had Castillo only fight I believe Floyd lost