the what fights did you watch today\scorecard thread.

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Mantequilla, Nov 20, 2009.


  1. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Jones Jr vs Hopkins.

    The first 7 rounds are all the same thing. Hopkins tries to pin Jones behind his jab, get himself into range and then get his shots off. The problem is Jones is just too quick. Jones doesn't have the success with his leaping hook, but jabs and arm punches mean he comfortably outland Hopkins every round. Hopkins never really pushes the pace, he sticks to his losing strategy. These 7 rounds remind me of a game of chess where someone loses a pawn early on and try as they might they can't quite ever make it back up.

    The commentators mention how Jones avoids the jab by leaning back and to date only Ali has been able to get away with it, but it reminds me of Fitzsimmons also.

    Also the commentary really rip into Bowe for facing Ferguson. They reckon its the worst title defence in history lol.

    Round 8 is a bit of a different story, Hopkins finally gets himself in range and lands a series of right hands over the top that bother Jones. I'm not fully sure Hopkins deserves this round but he's getting it. 7-1 Jones

    Round 9 Hopkins comes out more confidently and a bit more aggressive, he thinks he's figured Jones out and it willing to now force the action, but this just means Jones gets a chance to shine, he works Hopkins to the body, gets out of range and is able to pick his shots very effectively. 8-1 Jones.

    Round 10 is the best round by Jones so far imo. His leaping hooks are sinking in, as Hopkins moves in Jones throws his shoe shine hook combinations. Jones is able to snipe every time Hopkins tried setting his feet. Hopkins looks like he felt some of those big shots as well.

    Round 11 and 12 ,this looks like the Hopkins we became accustomed to seeing. Active, coming in behind his head, working the body, slipping and following the right hand in. Jones lands some good shots but I think overall Hopkins does the better work here. Its a shame it has taken him so long to get going. Hopkins looks to be unsettling the rhythm of Jones here. History tells us Hopkins has the conditioning to keep this kind of fight going for the full 12, a rematch would have been interesting.

    9-3 or 117-111 to Jones Jr.
     
    JohnThomas1 likes this.
  2. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Jones Jr vs Tate.

    It's interesting, despite dominating the first round Jones doesn't get an awful lot of credit by the commentary.

    They go on about how he lost the last two rounds to Hopkins, potentially has cardio issues.

    They say Tate can take his power and is about to present Jones with problems down the stretch.

    But then round 2 starts and the leaping left hook ends affairs immediately. The commentary seem shocked, its amazing the thought of not knowing Jones is a master at the leaping left hook.

    His feet are all over the place as he throws it, but the power is brutally there.

    Excellent win.
     
    George Crowcroft likes this.
  3. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Toney vs Jones Jr

    The build up for this is really good actually. They try to draw parallels with Jones Jr and Leonard in terms of style, Leonard has none of it he says how good Jones is with the hook and getting in and out of range.

    Then there's a really cool montage of MW bouts throughout the year, shows some pictures of Greb vs Walker, some footage of Zale vs Graziano and some footage of Ketchel and klaus.

    The commentary then absolutely rip into Jones saying right now he's basically a fraud, is refusing to fight top competition, won't engage with any top middleweights and they don't know how true his talent actually is. But they caveat that by accepting he's moving up in weight to face Toney, although they say Toney is having a lot of issues with weight so they don't seem too impressed. Toney has put over a stone back on and had to lose 40 pounds in camp.

    There's absolutely zero mention of P4P here in the buildup. But they concede its a 50/50 fight depending on how good Jones truly is.

    The fight itself is a bit more entertaining than I remember. Toney has zero urgency at any point, but Jones does try to put on a show and wants to open Toney up.

    Toney gets dropped and survives, that's basically it.

    This time I have no sympathy rounds.

    120-107 to Jones
     
    JohnThomas1 likes this.
  4. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Jones Jr vs Thornton

    This is basically a re run of the Tate fight. Jones lands anything he wants, whenever he wants until his opponent crumbles.
     
  5. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Jones Jr vs Griffin

    First round Jones doesn't do anything of note really. Griffin pressures well behind the jab and works Jones up against the ropes. 1-0 Griffin

    Round 2 is another good round for Griffin. Hes making Jones miss, backing him up and lands some tasty left hooks as well. 2-0 Griffin

    Griffin has started this fight very Archie Moore esque. He's been slowly pressing him, trying to look for counter opportunities. A good blend of timing and pressure boxing.

    Round 3, somehow Griffin is winning the jabbing exchanges despite being much shorter with a much shorter reach. Griffin again gets through with the left hook and again is able to drive him back to the ropes. 3-0 Griffin.

    Round 4 starts a bit more cautiously, but Griffin is proving here that timing kills speed. Jones is just missing from range whilst Griffin is backing Jones up and scoring up close. Griffin really is fighting a perfect fight here. 4-0 Griffin.

    Round 5 sees Jones start to get off a bit more now. Griffin seems to have slowed just a tad and Jones lands the cleaner work. 4-1 Griffin.

    Round 6 the pace has dramatically increased here. Jones senses he needs to be doing something big so starts forcing the action. Griffin tries to meet fire with fire to slow Jones down again but Jone is definitely coming off the better o it if the exchanges now. 4-2 Griffin

    Round 7 was a very close round, but Jones scores a dubious knockdown so it's actually an easy one to score. 4-3 Griffin.

    Round 8 is a good round for Griffin who shows no ill effects from the dubious knockdown. Griffin can't seem to miss with the left hook. He's started to really mark Jones up now as well. Jones just doesn't seem to have enough room to stay away from Montell. 5-3 Griffin.

    Round 9 Griffin is having more success but Jones lands a good left hook as Griffin comes inside to back him up, Griffin shakes it off and gets back to work. Griffin doesn't quite slip a right hand it rocks him to the core, Jones is chasing him around the ring, the round is coming to an end and Griffin takes a knee, as he's down Jones hits him, blatantly.

    DQ to Griffin.

    Jones looks very, very beatable on this fight. I think there's every chance Griffin sees out the ring and gets a points victory had Jones not hit him when down.

    75-75 at the time of the DQ.
     
  6. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    Trainer vs Manager dispute about money. Futch wasn't happy, Griffin sides with his manager.

    Futch is shown the door.

    Griffin is hurt by the first punch Jones throws. he knocks him down with the second hook he throws. Griffin settles back into it again but Jones tries walking through Griffin to prove he is a class above. The technical start we saw last time out isn't being followed here. Griffin tries to re establish his jab but Jones is still able to get through with his left hooks.

    As Griffin crouches Jones times him perfectly and near decapitated Griffin.
     
    George Crowcroft likes this.
  7. lufcrazy

    lufcrazy requiescat in pace Full Member

    80,680
    21,298
    Sep 15, 2009
    I was gonna watch some Glen Johnson and Gennady Golovkin. But I cba with the first name and I remember the fights of the 2nd too well to rewatch them.

    Gonna watch some Dick Tiger next.
     
    George Crowcroft likes this.
  8. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,314
    12,597
    Mar 2, 2006
    I watched Frank Bruno v Carl 'The Truth' Williams today and it was an OK heavyweight fight. This wasn't the same Williams who was duking it out with Larry Holmes a number of years earlier, but he still gave Bruno some exercise. No use running a card here. I gave Williams the 3rd round and a share of the 6th. The other seven to Bruno for an 89-83 scorecard through 9 completed rounds until Frank lowered the boom in the 10th. Not sure if the 10 point system was employed or the British scoring. I know Bruno fought his previous fight against Coetzer with a 10 point scoring, so I went with that. I should mention - although I've seen a good number of Bruno's bouts - how amazed I was at how dirty he fought, which wasn't necessary against this version of opponent. From the first round it was holding and hitting, rabbit punching, low blows and use of the forearm, while referee Dave Parris barely threw out a few cautions. Bruno was better than that and British refereeing was better than that.
     
  9. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    23,181
    26,209
    Jun 26, 2009
    British refereeing is fine if it’s Brit vs.Brit but otherwise it’s almost always rubbish ... whatever the homeland lad needs is how it goes.

    It’s been ages since I’ve seen the old UK scoring system with half points and can’t for the life of me remember how that worked. Can you offer a refresher?
     
  10. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,314
    12,597
    Mar 2, 2006
    Pat, I am certainly no expert or even well-versed in the British scoring system, although I would love to learn. At one time they were using a 5-4 3/4 points spread for the winner and loser of a round. This system was used in fights like Saldivar v Winstone II and Frazier v Bugner. Later I see it possibly morphed into a 10-9 1/2 point spread for winner and loser of a round like Rosario v Randall I. But again, I'm not sure. And if one of our British friends here can elaborate for us, we'd be all the better for it.
     
    Saintpat likes this.
  11. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    112,774
    47,620
    Mar 21, 2007
    Juan Carlos Payano SD 12 Rau'shee Warren

    Both these fights were better than decent. Swift-handed technically astute tough guys at or near the top of the bantamweight division. Too much lunging in the first though for them to pass that technically astute bar, Payano probably puts them together a little better though Warren's jab looks ominous. Also ominous is Payano's relationship with the referee, he's been warned repeatedly for pushing, shouldering and hitting the kidneys by the end of the second, which he nearly to a beautiful Warren counter-hook - he is busier though and I like him in the second, barely.

    Adrien Broner sits in on commentary for the third round and is humble and respectful. I swear. Payano has a point taken from him for hitting behind the head, but more from a series of fouls. Commentary didn't notice those warnings, somehow, and are complaining that he wasn't warned enough before having the point taken off. It's a valid deduction. Of more significant is the very hard right hand counter Warren uses to take the round, so things are all square after three.

    Payano appears to be a teeny bit stronger and that matters because they're spending a lot of time inside with a referee who is letting them work. Payano maintains aggression, Warren sees him off with a low blow in the fourth and actually ends up rolling about on the canvas, nearly off it. The low blow was real and deliberate. Pretty delicate punch but you never know with the balls. Warren needs to add shots. He's doing well with single shots but Payano is throwing uglier punches in higher volumes but enough is getting home to win him rounds. Steve Farhood disagrees with me; he has Warren a point up. I do have him winning the fifth, and Payano has also been cut by the right eye.

    Rough, tough fight. Warren has started to hit hard to the body up close in a free-wheeling way - needed. Both fighters are receiving warnings for rough tactics, mainly Payano though and I wouldn't be surprised to see another deduction for either or both. Warren has adjusted for me and is deploying his own volume now, but it doesn't seem to suit hm - he looks tired in the seventh. That's early in a fight this tough. Another head clash in round eight, another cut for Payano who looks troubled by this one. It leads to savage infighting. Warern dominates much of the action but fades big in the final 90 seconds. Close, vicious round.

    In the ninth, Waren has two points taken from him for throwing Warren to the ground and hitting him on the deck; it looked a bit much but Steve Farhood clears this up - the rule here is that a deliberate punch on a fallen opponent is two points regardless. Another headclash - Payano is a mess and the doctor is called up. He has two bad cuts and he looks like he might quit to the cards but I should know better really. I will say this though, i've never seen a doctor look at a fighter for so long without stopping the fight. Warren feels Payano has shown weakness too and attacks him viously before pushing him to the canvas. Somehow, no further point is deducted. Very difficult for the referee this who tells Warren he will DQ him if he fouls like that again. Payano looks all in.

    What a fun, crazy fight.

    Payano opens the tenth with real aggression, he probably feels it is slipping a bit; Warren comes back, pushes with the shoulder, takes a chance, referee warns him, looks really pissed. Payano wins the 10th I think, but to make things even more controversial, I thought Warren dropped Payano with a right hand clipper, more a stumble, a shattered fall, but there was a punch that went in. That probably would have sealed it for Warren so it really matters. The KD is arguable though, I fall on the side of Warren however. Either way, great, great round.

    An exhausted Payano gets dropped in the twelfth and Warren seals the decision for me on my card. Any close card is fine by me. Fun, savage, vicious fight, good they fought an immediate rematch.

    Payano:1,2,4,7,10.
    Warren:3*,5,6,8,9^,11,12+.

    113-111 Warren.

    *Payano has a point taken off for repeated fouling.
    ^Warren has two points taken off for
    +Payano down.
     
  12. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    112,774
    47,620
    Mar 21, 2007
    Rau'shee Warren MD 12 Juan Carlos Payano

    Fight feels different. Nice hooks from Warren to bag the first, he looks slightly faster-handed and determined this time to take proper advantage. Warren sort of shucking his way into range, sliding out to his left and right when Payano closes on him. Very good first round from Warren, he looks excellent. Has a very good second too - Payano has his first successes behind the jab though. Good fight already. Warren even looks bigger this time around. He holds his trailing left poised while he jabs; Payano maybe is a bit spooked. He's starting to find Warren though, very reliant upon the jab a the moment but we all know what that can open up.

    Warren throws mad punches in the first minute of the fourth though, aggressive, driving forwards, discombobulating Payano badly with the reverse. Then he settles. Pretty masterful. Payano has a long way back to win the round and he knows that. He does win a dunt of what remains but it's not enough. Key fifth-round coming up. Warren spends the first half of the round forgetting to punch; still moving well, but not punching well. Payano out-hustles him through the first two minutes. It's not glorious quality he is landing but it's good enough to take the fifth, and Warren is warned for holding.

    Payano warned for holding in the sixth though, after another very fast, limber start from Warren. These fast starts do wonder sfor him - hard to see a way back in for Payano. I think Payano manages it though; Warren is tiring a bit and I think he drops much of what remains. So I have it all square. Warren steals the seventh right out form under Payano with a gorgeous countering swarm - he hasn't been behind yet in the fight. Payano evens it up on aggression in the eighth though. Warren looks like he's resting. I think he thinks he has more control than he does, though it's worth noting that TV commentary has warren 6-2 up. The ninth has a different flavour as Warren seeks to force his way forwards late in the round with big punches, preventing Payano form out-working him. He looks like the clearly better fighter again, as he seemed in the first, but Payano comes right back at him and throws volume in range. That was a great ebb and flow in that round - I think I favour Payano making him leader for the first time.

    Warren comes crashing back in the eleventh, hitting Payano often and hard, out-speeding and out-hitting him, fighting with face-first aggression in a shocking turnaround. He closes it up for me in the final rounds of what was a dramatic and underrated series. Shame there was no third fight. I have it a draw; probably the right man won if one of them had to win. Payano threw some amount of punches though.

    Warren:1,2,4,7,11,12.
    Payano:3,5,6,8,9,10.

    114-114 Draw
     
  13. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    23,181
    26,209
    Jun 26, 2009
    James Toney vs. Mike McCallum I on Dec. 13, 1991, from the Convention Hall in Atlantic City, NJ, for Toney’s IBF middleweight championship.

    Tony, 25, was 28-0-1 (20) and weighed 159. McCallum, 34, was 42-1 (34) and weighed 157 3/4.

    This was really, basically, a unification fight except that the WBA stripped McCallum of their strap because his side balked after agreeing to step-aside money to make Steve Collins wait and then the WBA stepping in at the last minute to up the ante and try to force McCallum to pay an even higher premium.

    (Collins, for his part, contested for the vacated crown in April of 1992 and lost to Reggie Johnson for his trouble. Julian Jackson was the WBC champ at this time.)

    Round/Toney/McCallum

    1. 9-10

    2. 10-9

    3. 10-9

    4. 9-10

    5. 10-9

    6. 10-9

    7. 9-10

    8. 9-10

    9. 9-10

    10. 10-9

    11. 9-10

    12. 10-9

    My card: 114-114

    Official cards: 115-113 McCallum, 115-112 Toney, 114-114 even

    Split draw.

    This is the Sweet Science at its finest. McCallum is so crafty and works that jab and those subtle body punches so well. Toney lands the bigger shots and does most of what damage was done but isn’t quite as consistent.

    There are four to six rounds in this fight that you can easily argue either way depending on what you like. It’s just a marvelous display of skill.

    BTW, the commentary on this TVKO PPV bout is pretty lousy — it’s one of the Goosens (Joe?) and Marvelous Marvin Hagler and a play-by-play guy (Len Berman, not sure) and they spend half the fight talking about how McCallum is breathing hard and failing to notice it’s because he’s out-working Toney — James fights in spurts and whether his mouth is open or not (as McCallum’s was) if he’s not punching I don’t see why it matters that the other guy ‘looks’ tired.

    Also of note, this bout drew a crowd of just 4,308 for what was billed (up until the last minute) as a middleweight title unification. Sad.

    If you haven’t seen their trilogy, I urge to you watch it. If you have, watch it again. (G)
     
    Jel likes this.
  14. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,314
    12,597
    Mar 2, 2006
    Needed a good old toe-to-toe today to clear the head and I alighted on Felix Trinidad v Ricardo Mayorga. Here we go.

    Round 1: 10-9 Trinidad
    Round 2: 10-9 Trinidad
    Round 3: 10-8 Mayorga (scores a flash knockdown)
    Round 4: 10-10 Even
    Round 5: 10-8 Trinidad (dishes out a battering)
    Round 6: 10-9 Trinidad
    Round 7: 10-9 Mayorga
    Round 8: Tito drops Mayorga 3 times and the fight is stopped

    Total (through 7 completed rounds): 67-65 Trinidad (actual scores: 68-64, 68-64 and 67-64 all for Trinidad)

    A terrific old barn-burner was just the ticket today. Both landed their shots but Tito's were more precise and wicked. Loved it. BTW, the knockdown scored by Mayorga may have been official, but it was more of a Trinidad glove touching down steadying himself. But it is what it is.
     
    Jel and George Crowcroft like this.
  15. George Crowcroft

    George Crowcroft He Who Saw The Deep Full Member

    27,126
    44,867
    Mar 3, 2019
    Scar, I had it pretty similar. Although I never scored a round even. I thought it was more of a beating than a slugfest, but I don't like Mayorga, so it was just as entertaining to me. I thought Tito looked as sharp as he did vs Joppy IMO which is amazing considering his long lay off.

    This content is protected

    10 : 9
    10 : 9
    8 : 10
    10 : 9
    10 : 8
    10 : 9
    10 : 9 (
    This content is protected
    )
    This content is protected