Yes to boil it down. It is the difference between making a judgement based on facts, compared to making a judgement based on feelings. I think it is always more accurate to go mainly based on the facts, and in this case; Who has the better top 3 wins?
It can be judged on both things. The eye test and the wins. Look at Junior with Abraham, Korobov and DeGale on his ‘win’ record, which are 3 excellent names yet all 3 were shot to pieces. It all depends on the context.
The ranking of the 3 best wins does depend on what state the fighter was in when you got the win. No one in their right mind would claim that Tarver's wins against Roy Jones Jr are worth the same as Enzo Mac's. Tarver took Roys boxing virginity away from him
And beat Parker, Helenius, Rivas... And Wilder himself went life and death with Molina, Duhaupas, ans Szpilka.
This has nothing to do with anything. Its boxing, not barfighting. Whyte has beaten better competition than Ortiz, or, for that matter, Wilder. That is all.
Parker stabdout win od career, used his head to concuse Parker, which i dint blame jim for as uts a fight and he done well avoiding being knocked out in 12th. Rivas is no great shake and Helenius is poor. Most had Chisora winning first fight (i scored it a draw at time).
Good! No need for a rematch, wasn't even close, wilder got battered pillow to post nothing to do with his outfit that's bollox he just got out fought out powered everything fury is simply a bigger better skilled fighter than bum squad!! Fury beats him if the 3rd happens hes shown that he can take his best shots that punch that put him asleep for a few seconds Joshua wouldn't got up from that no chance that would of kod 99 percent of the current heavyweights. There's only one tyson fury!!
I've been saying Wilder is a fraud for years. He got elevated to the status of the most dangerous heavyweight in history by many off the back of beating Uber drivers, teaching assistants, pastry chefs and football hooligans. The real danger men of the division like prime Mike Tyson, Foreman, Lewis, Vit, WK and a good deal more would end Wilder in a few rounds.
Parker is better than Wilder's best win of Ortiz, and Wilder was visibly saved by the ref on the first fight, so hey, Whyte is still better.