P4P Comparison - Inoue vs Ryan Garcia

With all the crazy talk going on about Inoue being P4P #1, and discussing fighter's flaws, instead of comparing him to Canelo, why don't we compare him to a guy more his size.

How does Inoue compare to Ryan Garcia P4P? I don't see Ryan Garcia in too many P4P lists but personally I see him and Inoue as a fascinating comparison as to who should be higher P4P. Both have exactly 20 fights, both have 20 wins and both have 17 KOs.

But who's better P4P? A poster said one of Inoue's flaws is his defense. That's a big part of P4P isn't it? Ryan Garcia has much better defense than Inoue don't you think and is more of a pure boxer than Inoue. Pure boxers with solid fundamentals and defense typically end up higher P4P. So why isn't Ryan Garcia in the P4P conversation and what makes Inoue deserve to be higher than him?

 

Give me a break. How do you rate Ryan Garcia and how does he compare to Inoue P4P? If you think Inoue is better P4P fine, but I want to hear the arguments and counter arguments for that. Surely Garcia has much better defense and fundamentals than Inoue. But is Inoue more explosive and athletic? I think so. This seems to be a very relevant and interesting comparison.

 

What's the deal with your sexuality based comments? It's cringe city to be trying to have a legit boxing comparison and then you come along acting like a 16 year old school girl.

 

"Hating" on Inoue? Bro this topic is off the heels of a hilarious Inoue P4P #1 topic in which people are actually arguing that Inoue is better P4P than Canelo lmao. Bro the amount of hate on Canelo is off the charts around here. Even if I was hating on Inoue, which I'm not, it would be a drop in the bucket to the hate that Canelo gets around here.

So again I'll pose the question HOW do Ryan Garcia and Inoue compare P4P? What makes Inoue better P4P. EXPLAIN! Make your arguemnts if you believe Inoue is better! This is a much more relevant and better comparison than Inoue and Canelo which is flat out laughable.

 

LOL nice avator pic btw lol I guess you got other things on your mind huh.

 

What has Inoue accomplished? Who has he beat? Beating an almost 37 year old Donaire? That's what makes Inoue more deserving not his skills?

 

Isn't it funny how you use the argument that Ryan Garcia hasn't fought anyone to say that Inoue shoud be higher P4P but I make the same argument about Canelo and all the people he fought but that doesn't matter anymore? Compared to Canelo, both Inoue and Ryan Garcia hasn't fought anyone in the realm of the guys that Canelo fought. I mean lets face it there's not that many big names at the lower weights but ask yourself is the competition in Japan better or worse than in the USA? The vast majority would say USA has the best competition that's where Garcia has fought most of his fights.

Lets take Ryan Garcia's last opponent. Francisco Fonseca. He is 27-3-2. His losses are to Tank Davis, Tevin Farmer and Ryan Garcia. That's a respectable opponent is it not? The guy Garcia actually fought top fighters like Tank and Farmer. Jason Moloney hasnt fought fighters as good as Tank or Farmer. Rodriguez was undefeated when he fought Inoue, but ask yourself if Rodriguez had fought Tank or Farmer he'd have 2 losses too.