No Middleweight in History would have beaten prime Golovkin with fair judges

Don't think so.

 

Hagler... That is all

 

That assertion is unprovable especially in the elite circles of Middleweight one of the deepest boxing divisions and that's coming from a huge Golovkin fan. There have been some crazy talents and records in the division. Jones, Hopkins, Toney, Hagler, Monzon are just the latest in a long line of badasses that go all the way to Robinson, LaMotta, Steele, Greb and so forth.

I do think you could argue for him against anybody and I think he'd give anybody a hard fight at MW.

 

Yes.

 

If he’s so great why hasn’t he unified

 

I think we should simulate it on fight night.

GGG v Hopkins
RJJ v Monzon
Hagler v S.Martinez
Canelo v Pavlik

 

Well I know when he fights a good fighter, ahem Canelo, he looks ordinary Regardless of whether you think he lost because of the judges, both were close fights. To say that he beats everyone in history at this division is a stretch. But of course now you will say Canelo beats everyone in history too to elevate GGG.

GGG just beat his mandatory, nothing has changed. Canelo is still better IMHO. That's just in this era.

 

Prime GGG surely loses vs these 2 Middleweights...

* Ezzard Charles, 15 rounds of humiliation
* Edgar Berlanga, Fast-life destruction

 

P4P King Canelo lost to an old GG twice, what does that make GGG?

 

Lol all great MWs at least had the competition to back up this claim.. Unfortunately GGG don’t, so like Bud Crawford we don’t know. And it’s easy to point out the first Canelo fight and say he won(I think he did) but that mean we should take a deeper look at how great Canelo is.. Literally every B+/A level opponent Canelo has faced has ended in controversy.. Lara might have won, Trout fight was very close, Cotto was close and the GGG fights were extremely close..

 

How would you actually go and prove this? Build a time machine? Are you a ****ing idiot?

 

he loses to a few for sure.

 

We can say one thing, GGG would be very competetive with any MW in history

 

GGG beats everyone, but loses to Inoue.