Found this list on r/boxing a subreddit on reddit, what are thoughts on this P4P list? Rank Name Record +/- 1 Canelo Alvarez 53-1-2 - 2 Naoya Inoue 20-0 +2 3 Terence Crawford 37-0 - 4 Errol Spence Jr 26-0 +1 5 Oleksandr Usyk 18-0 +1 6 Vasyl Lomachenko 14-2 -4 7 Teofimo Lopez 16-0 New 8 Tyson Fury 30-0-1 New 9 Manny Pacquiao 62-7-2 -1 10 Gennadiy Golovkin 40-1-1 -3
F**k r/boxing and the fascists who run the sub. Anyway Fury shouldn’t be on the list. Spence is too high and Crawford should be below Usyk. Taylor should be on the bottom end of the list.
I’ve been banned so long I can’t remember which are the okay ones and which ones are d**ks. One of the newer Wilder bum boys mods banned me I think.
I’m only considering Usyk the cruiserweight and not Usyk the heavyweight. The heavyweight Usyk gets smashed to pieces by Joshua and Fury and probably levelled by Wilder while up on all the cards.
Not a bad list. I’m not sure GGG deserves his spot but maybe he will prove me wrong. Better than the POS lists I’ve seen with Tank Davis in top ten. A guy who has never fought a top fighter at his current weight. Fury deserves a spot, maybe higher. He’s a generational talent when he’s in top form.
I feel Usyk will beat AJ and Fury but the point I was making is that Bud deserves to be rated above Usyk based on their last performances.
One of the better lists I have seen. I agree with Loma ahead of Lopez because of Loma's whole career. I'm a big GGG fan but I don't think he should be there. Josh Taylor should be in everyone's top 10, and potentially Estrada too.
Usyk will be found out at heavyweight. Simply too small and doesn’t have the skill or youth to overcome his disadvantages and beat these behemoths.
There's some good stuff on reddit but I've always wondered whether the vast hoardes of indistinguishable posters surround the quality were all the same before they got there or if reddit did it to them. For the list, I think Fury's not really cut out for P4P since his biggest win since Wlad was someone he outweighed by 40lbs. I think Estrada should be in there, perhaps instead of Pac.