Greater Fighter: Calzaghe or GGG?

Both ATG in their respective weight classes.

GGG in 160lb.
Sir Joe calzaghe in 168lb

Both Undefeated. But I have to go with Welsh dragon on any head to head. Probably the only man that could beat GGG without dogdy refs and peds.

 

Calzaghe's extra size would be problematic to say nothing of his handspeed. That's a fight I wouldn't want to bet on.

 

Both Undefeated? Haha I guess you forgot about the time GGG lost. Remember to that guy, what was his name, oh yeah - Canelo, the man who GGG should call sir.

But of course I can understand why you would want to block that loss out of your mind. It must be a painful memory for you.

It was a painful memory for GGG as well, but it was so nice to see GGG give Canelo a big hug afterwards -

https://www.ocregister.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/LDN-L-GGG-CANELO-FIGHT-0916-6_268145372.jpg

 

Calzaghe, had the better resume and won belts in different weight classes. As of now, id say Calzaghe.

 

https://www.boxingnews24.com/2018/09/atlas-criticizes-judges-scoring-of-canelo-golovkin-2-fight/

Guess what, I watch fights with my own two eyes and I decide who won the fight, not some crooked ref.
And seeing as my scoring is usually in line with Teddy Atlas, I am not in bad company.

Where as your scoring is more inline with Adalaine Byrd, i wonder why? I say good luck to you shadow.

This content is protected

 

Why should I read your posts in a Jamaican accent mon?

 

LOL you watch fights with your own two eyes, but you reference Teddy Atlas. Wow you listen to a guy who has blurry vision and is known to have crazy scorecards. Remember when he interviewed Jeff Horn after he beat Pacquiao and said he lost. Atlas has a long history of scoring fights based on his own expectation of what he thinks is gonna happen. Atlas ego is so big he would never admit his prediction is wrong.

 

Calzaghe and it isn't particularly close imo

 

@timeout This is the guy you rely on for scoring?

Stephen A. Smith, Teddy Atlas got to screaming about Mayweather-McGregor and cheeseburgers
https://awfulannouncing.com/espn/stephen-a-smith-teddy-atlas-screaming-mayweather-mcgregor.html

ESPN has pulled boxing analyst Teddy Atlas from calling live fights
https://awfulannouncing.com/espn/espn-has-pulled-teddy-atlas-from-live-fights.html

That explains a lot lol.

 

I have to go with big Joe.

 

Not even close
Easily Calzaghe

What is Golovkins biggest mw win? Jacobs maybe?
Calzaghe has several bigger wins and I do mean several

 

Calzaghe hands down. He's a true ATG who would be great in any era. Calzaghe would clown GGG at 168.

 

Better fighter? GGG
Greater fighter? Calzaghe

 

Greater fighter: GGG. Hits harder, better chin. Avoided in his prime.

Greater Boxer: Calzaghe. Faster hands, better work rate. Didn’t leave the UK in his prime.