Jermell Charlo has a pretty good resume. Much better than his brother's, at least. He holds wins over Harrison, Rosario, and Trout. If he beats Castano and becomes, undisputed, surely he makes the top 10 P4P. But where would he rank?
If Jermell Charlo wins, he will: Retain: WBC WBA (Super) Champion IBF Ring Magazine title Gain: WBO He will be undisputed champion at 154 and have cleaned out the division. Avenged his sole defeat with a decisive KO and not had and victories that warrant a rematch either. If this is enough for Josh Taylor fan's to be screeching that he should be in the P4P list then it should also be good enough for Charlo.
A resume of castano, Trout and Harrison enough to get in the p4p list? Not for me. Yes he would be unified champion but its very poor division.
P4P isn't just about resume & wins tho, its about skill & Charlo lost most most of the rounds he fought with Harrison.. he couldn't even stop men like Rosado.. if he's so special he should be walking through guys like that.. Castano is a good win but I still wouldn't put him top 10.. and let's be honest Charlo has a massive height and reach advantage over this guy too.. he's massive for 154.. He's bigger than a lot of MWs.. I bet he walks around at about 180lbs.. whereas Castano looks like a bloated WW
Well, pure logic. Undeniable. But I dont think that taylor is top 10 p4p worthy. And I dont think charlo is either. But... What you have said is undeniable, if it's good enough for josh, then, it's good enough for charlo.