Who is the best fighter from every weight class?

HW - Joe Louis
LHW - Ezzard Charles
MW - Ray Robinson / Marvin Hagler
WW - Ray Robinson
LW - Roberto Duran / Pernell Whittaker
FW - Willie Pep
BW - Eder Jofre
fW - Not sure about this weight class.

 

HW: Muhammad Ali
LHW: Ezzard Charles
MW: Marvin Hagler
WW: Sugar Ray Robinson
LW: Roberto Duran
FW: Henry Armstrong
BW: Ruben Olivares
Fly: Fighting Harada

 

Heavyweight : Muhammad Ali
Light Heavyweight : Ezzard Charles
Middleweight : Harry Greb
Welterweight : Sugar Ray Robinson
Lightweight : Benny Leonard
Featherweight : Willie Pep
Bantamweight : Ruben Olivares
Flyweight : Miguel Canto

Mind you, I'm only taking into acount their accomplishments in the particular weight division, I actually rank Duran, Armstrong and Wilde above Leonard, Pep, Canto overall respectively, but they just didn't do as much in those particular divisions to be put above them.

 

HW: Muhammad Ali (H2H), Tie: Joe Louis + M. Ali (Record / Legacy)
LHW: Ezzard Charles (H2H) / Archie Moore (Record / Legacy)
MW: Marvin Hagler H2H & Legacy
WW: Sugar Ray Robinson H2H & Legacy

Don't know much about the lighter weight classes. It lacks of my interests...but i really like PW!
(I just considered fighters where i can rely on a good amount of video footage, no hearsay and newspaper stuff)

 

HW - Louis
LHW - Charles
MW - Kalambay
WW - Duran
LW - Duran
FW - Armstrong

 

Rummy did a survey, with a video for the results last year; it is pinned at the top of the forum:

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/top-35-all-time-reveal-boxing-survey-series.653021/

 

Ali
Charles
Greb
Robinson
B. Leonard
Pep
Jofre
Wilde

 

Sure some people would have a consensus, sure, i.e Greb, Armstrong, SRR

for me Louis at HW.

But the truth is, there are many, and as I say, the differences at the TOP are little, that is more the Truth in a 150 years of Hundreds of Great Fighters.

GREAT, Great, great,
Excellent,
Very Good,

that sort of thing.

 

Heavy-DEMPSEY
Lt-Heavy-TUNNEY
Middle-MONZON
Welter-ROBINSON
Light-DURAN
Feather-PEP/SANCHEZ
Bantam-ZARATE
Fly-CANTO

 

Kalamby , you aving a laugh buddy !!! keep well.

 

For me, pretty much perfect.... keep well.

 

Lack of Greb due to lack of footage?

 

Hagler has more votes than Monzon