HW: Muhammad Ali, Joe Louis LHW: Ezzard Charles, Sam Langford MW: Bob Fitzsimmons, Harry Greb WW: Sugar Ray Robinson, Sugar Ray Leonard LW: Roberto Duran, Benny Leonard FW: Henry Armstrong, Willie Pep
Yes. I can't call somebody I've never seen, the best I've ever seen - no matter how good his record is.
Well, we know that Nunn sparked him. I'd expect Hagler, SRR, RJJ and B-Hop to beat him - I'd also expect Monzon to do so too.
It was one of those fluke one-off shots. Nunn closed his eyes and was shocked himself. He’d beat them all barring Monzon.
Heavyweight - Ali Light Heavyweight - Spinks Middleweight - Jones jr Welterweight - Robinson Lightweight - Whitaker Featherweight - Sanchez Bantamweight - Zarate Flyweight - Gonzalez
Heavyweight - Ali Light Heavyweight - Charles Middleweight - Robinson Welterweight - Robinson Lightweight - Duran Featherweight - Armstrong Bantamweight - Jofre Flyweight - Wilde
Good list JT, If I may, are you ranking on mix of record, H2H, p4p and film? I ask cos of SRR at MW - whilst I think he was the greatest fighter to be a MW champion, I don't think he was the best MW fighting champion if that makes sense? Likewise, whilst Duran is my best LW fighter, I would be okay with someone ranking Leonard above him as a LW champion.
H2H which seems to be the way the majority went before me. Best I've seen basically. So H2H and film. I'm in the group that think the earlier 160 Robinson via his very best version would do the best overall in a H2H tournament. The guy that beat LaMotta in the Valentines Day Massacre would be pretty hard to beat.
His disqualification against Griffin is not a true loss. He obliterated him in the rematch. And his losses after he dropped down from HW to LHW again are irrelevant.
