Bob Foster at SMW today- GOAT 49-0

Simply show me the fighters who dropped a weightclass after same day weigh ins ended. You're inventing **** that I didn't say instead and not coming across as a very bright person.

 

A strange one, you are. I asked first.

 

I hereby ask both of you, simultaneously. (Since I would like to hear both answers.)

 

https://www.boxing247.com/weblog/archives/110217

Two problems are that fight night weights weren’t really a thing when same day weigh ins were happening and old boxing magazines aren’t really searchable using Google. Eating disorders and weight cutting have long been in boxing. I remember reading about a bantam in the 80s who was doing crazy weight cuts and was bulimic….

The day before weigh in rule came about due to these issues. I assume certain fighters were still piling on weight after the weigh in, but what’s more scary is the ones entering the ring without recovering fully from the weight cut.

 

Okay, both of these are true statements. But what do they prove? They don't prove that Tiger was training down from 167 when he was much younger. 7 pounds wouldn't have created a problem for Tiger even back in the day.

Secondly, why are 30 pound cuts taken as the norm when they are very clearly not? There was only one mention of a purported 30 pound cut in this thread, but it remains unsubstantiated despite being called out.

Again, let's circle back to Gatti and examine this in-era comparison: why is Foster more like Gatti, and not someone like Vernon Forrest? Both Gatti and Forrest entered the ring in their primes in the high 140's or sometimes low 150's. Why couldn't Forrest ever make 130 to become Godzilla? Why didn't Tszyu or any of the people we have numbers on, for that matter? Why are you so sure Foster makes 160 without breaking a sweat, when he had to sweat to make 175?

Even if we take it for a fact that modern techniques have vastly improved, there is a limit to how much you can continue to drain a drained fighter.

 

@Kamikaze
You would also have to believe that water weight is an advantage in the ring for you to make a statement like "Jacobs and Marciano are almost the same size".

 

That's what happens when you drain down to Classicweight and take on a thread with a high posting tempo.

Once you rehydrate, I invite you to give it the old college try anyway.

Gratuitous banana:

 

Okay, so no response to any of my questions, but plenty of snide comments and out-of-context numbers. Gotcha.

Your own questions were answered, by the way. They just never came close to anything resembling a coherent point.

 

Foster was 182 for Ali. Presumably he didn't dehydrate himself for that.

Which modern division's in-ring unofficial weights cluster around the 182 mark? That's probably the safest answer for what Foster might have been able to dry out to.

EDIT: According to the website I posted of the guy who collects unofficial weights (for whatever reason) from HBO, lightheavyweight and supermiddleweight both have a fair number of fighters in the low 180s on fight night. Middleweight 180 pound guys are very rare, though. So supermiddleweight is probably the lowest one that we can postulate with reasonable certainty, unless I'm missing something?

 

Acetazolamide was invented in 1960.