A 14-year old fan's terribly inaccurate top 50 list

My suggestion is to have the 14 year old examine different fighters from the past or present, their matches. We are all talented posters on this site, if that youngster has any questions we are all here to answer any questions about the fighters and their fights. Everybody's opinions vary, but in the end it is important to show that 14 year old that his opinion is just as important as the opinion's of other posters. I have been watching boxing since 1965, my opinions of fighters may be different than the next guy, young or old.

 

That is good my friend, also concentrate on your education, it is very important. In the long run , having a good education is very important for your future. Any boxing questions, you can ask any of us.

 

Calzaghe is ridiculously high

 

Do you rate any other super middleweight over him?
Ward?Jones?Froch?Ottke?

 

Is your list based on the opinion of others or have you actually watched the fights?

 

Pound for pound is extremely tough. Not a bad list, overall.

 

Not a bad go. There’s no right answer for a list. I’d suggest doing an all-time top 10 or 20 in each division and an all-time ranking of each country of the country’s with multiple greats like USA, Mexico, Britain, Puerto Rico etc; and of continents like Asia, South America, Africa etc; then go from there.