If the Nightmare won..he would be like "Who nek? Who nek? And Eddie would be like, "well I got news for you fella"
Joshua would keep things long and box Peter at range. Prime Peter had a head like a rock though (he ate something like four or five flush Wlad right hands in their first fight without blinking), so I can foresee some hairy moments for Josh dealing with the Peter when he goes on one of his crazy caveman moments and starts clubbing Joshua about the back of the head with massive haymakers, and generally manhandling him. It's a fight Joshua would look bad in winning, like the second Ruiz fight but maybe a bit scrappier.
I prefer Joshua since he's the more refined product, but Peter was a rough, tough customer prime and hit like a truck. He'd have a chance to crack AJ's iffy chin.
Peter KO. Hits like a truck and has an iron chin. Bodybuilder goes unconscious for the first time in his career
Joshua in a very close fight by UD. In the first Wlad fight Peter had a titanium chin and massive power.
Depends on the Peter and the Ruiz versions (physical and mental shape for both). Peak for peak has the makings of a good fight.