Carlos Quintana vs. Oba Carr

I'm not biased, I'm answering the question on who would win between the two. In my opinion Carr would win hands down. If you don't agree that's fine but you will never convince me that Quintana is the superior fighter. Why even post the thread if you already have your mind made up?

 

He didn’t do **** to Oscar.

 

I guess landing 157 punches against a prime Oscar isn't **** then. In comparison Tito landed 166.

I am in know way saying that Carr was even close to beating Oscar. I'm saying he was a damn fine fighter that simply wasn't as good as Oscar, Tito and Ike who in my mind were all time great WW's.

 

I’d rather take 157 punches from Carr than 60 from Tito.

 

No argument here. Carr was not much of a banger. He had fast hands though and was tough as nails. Oscar clearly beat him but he wasn't going away quietly.