List of HW champs "Big" James Toney spanks-

Schmeling got robbed in the second fight, have you even see it? Also, have you seen Hamas rematch?

 

Schmeling stopped a lot of durable fighters. I'd certanly give him higher chance than most unskilled big brawlers from HW division.

 

Only watched the first one. The point is that Toney was well within their league.

 

You should know that it's well known robbery.

Your point is fair, but your argumentation simply isn't.

 

Add Joe Jeanette to this list of guys James would beat as HW. I'd say Langford vs Toney would be a back and forth very close fight. But as far as knocking James out you need to get him out of there with one shot. Because he's going to make whatever comes after it miss. I don't think Langford or Schmeling have that type of power. I think it's way more likely he goes to a decision with smaller guys. But a Tyson or a Lennox or a legit HW puncher could put him out in 1 punch.

 

Toney beats Braddock and Valuev. Possibly Carnera

 

Toney 2003 -2005 in my opinion beats -
sullivan
corbett
fitz
jeffries
hart
burns
johnson
willard
sharkey
carnera
baer
braddock
johannson

50-50 v schmeling, coetzee, berbick

loses to -
charles
walcott
marciano
patterson
liston
ali
frazier
foreman
norton
holmes
weaver

 

Generals the first door on the left kid

 

Kid??????????

Twat

 

Well within their league? Hmm? After moving to heavyweight in 2003 his record was 10-6-1 with 2 no contests.. 10 wins out of 19 fights.
A win over the corpse of Evander
he beat Fres Oquendo
NC with Ruiz
Draw and a NC with Rahman
2 losses to Peter
and a loss at cruiser in 2011 to Lebedev

That league ain't very high to say he'd beat Schmeling or a lot of heavyweight champs of the past

 

Your post gives me the feeling that you’ve never watched Toney’s second fight with Rahman, fight with Ruiz, and first fight with Peter. Jirov was also a quality champion who was roughly the size of Schmeling and Toney took him apart. They’re all on YouTube and decent enough fights.

Toney wasn’t consistent or good enough for me to think he’d be a long reigning heavyweight champion back then, but I also think he’d have success and probably beat guys like the Dempsey who Tunney beat.

 

Dontay Wilder is the 1st fighter to pop in my head. No real jab, telegraphed and over commits to his right hand , bad positioning, his defense is throwing up his arms. No real threat to counter punch.
Most skilled counter punchers in history ruined Wilder. Even a fat above best fighting weight one like Toney.

 

Here's my list