Who beat Canelo more convincingly: Mayweather, Golovkin the first time around or Bivol?

Bivol

 

Bivol beat the best version of Canelo and was more impressive doing it.

Bivol no brainer.

 

Bivol

The guy above said it perfectly. Beat the best version and did it in more dominant fashion than GGG and Mayweather

 

Bivol

 

I had:
Bivol winning 119-109
Mayweather winning 119-109
GGG winning (their 1st fight) 115-113

 

Bivol beat PRIME Canelo.

 

Mayweather easily he was 40 years old and won 12 rounds

 

Well GGG never beat Canelo, so it comes down to Mayweather or Bivol. But it was a better version of Canelo in GGG 1 than 175-lb Canelo vs Bivol or drained 152-lb Canelo vs Mayweather. In GGG 1, Canelo was far faster than he was last night, far more focused, had a better gameplan for GGG, had better defense, was a more accurate puncher, etc. So while you could say GGG didn't do as well againt Canelo as Mayweather or Bivol did, he also fought the better version of Canelo.

It's difficult to say who beat Canelo more convincingly Mayweather or Bivol. Very different weights and circumstances. I think you can make an argument either way. But in both cases, Canelo was at significant weight disadvantages and both fights were still very close on the cards. No one's ever beaten Canelo convincingly or otherwise without significant weight advantages.

 

Bivol won most comfortably, but I think Golovkin's performance was the most impressive. Canelo isn't really big enough for 175. He's a midget at that weight.

 

FYI Mayweather was 36, not 40. And he was P4P #1.

 

Bivol. The fight in reality was 12-0. At best 11-1 or 10-2 if you are somehow biased.
9-3 and anything else is hugely biased already.


GGG won 8-4 both fights quite easily as well, but Bivol just school him.

 

I do believe it’s a bit incorrect to say more convincingly as they fought in different weight divisions.

Sizewise Bivol had advantage, Mayweather had drained Canelo, while GGG didn’t have any physical advantage, nor weight advantage and had in my opinion the best Canelo version from what I’ve seen.