Floyd vs. GGG who wins?

I ethered your ass when you tried to make it like what Pac did against Mosley oscar and Hatton was better than what pbf did. I explained to you why you didn't know wtf you were talking about.

 

You didn't but that's cute, must of skipped your reply along with all your other tired tirades,

Take it easy bro your gonna blow yourself out getting so enraged, it's not that serious.

 

Oh yeah i did make my point clear regarding Pac beating those 3, just because you & your usual likening a post friends tipped your post means very little to me or my post, enjoy

 

This is silly.

Come on.

It’s not how great the fighters are.

It’s how they’d have matched up stylistically.


Floyd was on another planet to Murray. But he also had bad hands and was past his best at JMW. Murray was a decent fighter. A decent fighter who wouldn’t have let Floyd take the centre of the ring to dictate the pace of the fight. A world class MW would have fought Floyd aggressively and backed him up. A world class MW would have put Floyd on the defensive, which would have nullified his own offense.

We saw what Maidana did in their first fight, just 8 months after the Canelo masterclass.

We saw Oscar pressure him to the ropes where he covered up.

Floyd had a great defence. But whilst ever he covered up on the ropes, Oscar was awarded rounds for throwing and landing punches as the aggressor.

Martin Murray wouldn’t have played chess with Floyd. He’d have gone forward with pressure and made Floyd retreat. You can’t say that Murray couldn’t have won a round, when Maidana roughed him up and won rounds at WW. Stop being silly.

Iran Barkley wasn’t on the same planet as Michael Nunn and Thomas Hearns. Yet we saw what happened when they met.

There’s a reason that Floyd only ever fought 3 times above WW and never at MW.

Floyd vs Murray may actually produce a decent thread.


Floyd having shut out a guy who was competitive with GG has no relevance here.

Again, styles make fights, as well as the fact that the version of Canelo who faced GG, was not the same version of Canelo who’d fought Floyd, Lara and Trout.

 

No you didn't pac beat worse versions of all 3 while pbf beat better versions of all 3 prior.

 

You have Floyd beating the version of Bernard Hopkins that Oscar fought.

 

If GG wasn’t drained, he’d have relentlessly have pursued and pressured Floyd.

A 150 pound guy who was faded with bad hands.

GG’s style wouldn’t have changed.

It’s just whether or not he’d have been healthy.

If he’d have rehydrated healthily, he’d have been in the 160’s on fight night.

No version of GG would have stood off of Floyd like Canelo did in 2013.

You are way off the mark here.

Oscar and Cotto both gave Floyd competitive fights at JMW.

Maidana roughed him up at WW.

Floyd could never easily have beaten a healthy 154 pound GG.

 

The problem is ggg is not as good as Canelo or cotto or oscar. His resume or accomplishments don't suggest it. He's much slower than all 3 and has never fought at 154. I don't rate ggg like others have he was overhyped and underperformed. He's no where near as good as his fans make him out to be. The faded pbf who bear canelo would beat ggg at jmw, nothing will convince me otherwise.

 

Styles make fights. GGG will cut off the ring and put in on Floyd

 

Floyd Patterson by brutal KO!

 

Nah ggg is too slow for pbf of both hand and feet and he has shorter arms. He's never fought anyone as good as pbf. He's also a straight up and down fighter who pbf loves to fight. Pbf is a bad styles match up for him someone much faster than him who's not there to be hit, won't stand in front of him and fight his fight.

 

Again, silly logic.

How fast was Oscar, Cotto and Maidana?

How confident and offensive minded would a faded Floyd with bad hands have been, against a healthy 154 pound GG?

He wouldn’t have boxed circles around him.

GG wouldn’t have stood off of him, he’d have pressured him.

Do you seriously think he’d have had the time and the space to have pot shotted him etc?

Again, GG would have pursued him aggressively.

Floyd would have needed an offense to have won the fight.

 

Bro no GGG is too big for Floyd and theres no shame in it. If Floyd truly though he could beat GGG comfortably he would have fought him.

GGG would walk right through him and beat him down on the ropes because Mayweather has no power at welter, let alone 154. Canelo and GGG are different fighters.

The size difference is too much and GGG would be too agressive for Floyd as well. Sure if they were the same size Mayweather wins but they're not

 

Exactly.

Due to styles.

This was just 8 months after Canelo.

Maidana was a rough, pressure fighter who had no respect for Floyd.

Canelo was a passive counterpuncher who wouldn’t press Floyd.

GG would have backed Floyd up like Maidana did.

Maidana was crude.

A B level guy.

So why didn’t Floyd make it look like the Gatti fight??

 

Resume and ability are different things.

GG does have a weak resume. But a prime, healthy version of GG was a better fighter than those guys listed. The specific versions who Floyd fought.

How can a faded Shane have been better than a prime GG?

He wasn’t.

Neither were the others.