After each of any one of their fights the same thread is started about all 5 of them. We won't have a definitive answer until they fight each other. It seems like they will all be at 140 too, apart from Lomachenko, so I'd say Haney is probably the best out of all 5.
Garcia is probably the weakest out of the 5 after Tank. I can't see him beating the likes of Loma or Hainey.
He does have the talent to be an elite level fighter, but as things stand right now, he’s probably the most flawed on of the bunch, probably with the weakest resume yet.
I still like Loma over the others in this group but would love to see a LW tournament to force these guys to fight each other. Loma is on the shelf but will fight anyone in the group and I suspect will look to fight Haney before he moves to 140. I would pay for any of these guys to fight anyone in the list. Let’s just see it settled in the ring and not on Twitter or arguing in forums. It’s getting old and boring. Let the best man win.
How do Haney, Teo, Twink, and Garcia do in their third weight class trying to win all the titles individually in a division they don't belong in whilst always fighting on the road? But wait a moment.. they'd have to go up higher than that to be giving away the kind of physical advantages Loma is at 135, especially Haney Teo and Haney won them all in one fell swoop against opponents they're two divisions heavier than in a division they look like skeletor on crack at on the scales. How long do either last in their third division against the hardest punchers at that weight class like Super Boots Ennis? Because that's what Lopez is at 135 ie. the hardest puncher in the division with vicious one punch power in either hand This content is protected Loma is often giving away as much as 5.5'' in reach and fighting opponents who weigh close to two, two, or even three divisions in weight more than him against giants like Commey and surely Nakatani too The weight difference between Loma and the likes of Haney and Commey is roughly the same as it is between them and GGG Allow that sink into your abode Twink immediately ducked out of the fire escape up in his third division and scurried back down to 130-135 after harvesting another regular strap for his collection. He didn't hang around taking on all comers and the best the division had to offer like Loma did in his third weight class and Loma is giving away much bigger physical advantages in terms of weight and reach than he was against Barrios. Loma didn't just hang around in a division full of giants and power punchers he fought the #1 ranked guy in his debut at the weight Immediately jumped into a unification match up in his next fight at the weight against Pedraza even though he was coming off a career-threatening shoulder injury and surgery just seven months earlier And then he was set to jump right back into another unification match up in his next fight against IBF champ Commey until the later pulled out with an injury. So he accommodated his mandatory instead Then he added the WBC belt to his collection when he fought Campbell in his backyard And then in his very next fight he fought the murderous punching Teo in his backyard with a full set of home officials for undisputed Four of his first five fights at the weight were for new titles on the line and he put in all the hard work winning them individually on the road against fighters way bigger than him And then instead of opting for a lighter touch as the vast majority of fighters do after coming back from shoulder surgery (his second one) he took on the big punching giant Nakatani who gave Teofimo ''No More Tall Fighters'' Lopez 12 rounds of hell and was coming off a HL reel KO finish of talented Verdejo And then he fought the massive punching KO82% former champ Commey in his next fight after Teo ducked the rematch All those guys are way bigger and heavier than him