The Classic BN24 Hall of Legends: Rules, Opinions, Link to the HoF polling threads, 2023 intake chat

I've changed my mind, I think one per year and one every other year for between divisions. Let's create a strong HOF.

 

Three, I think.

 

In that case I have to propose affirmative action. 4 a year in general division and at least 1 a year from below 126.

 

Three in total across all divisions seems a reasonable number.

 

I skimmed it at work my bad. Three sounds good to me yeah.

 

One. Think that will prevent unworthy ones from being entered. If someone is that good they’ll make it the next year if they miss it…

 

Three seems fair to me Matt.

 

I think every year thereafter, after discussion, YOU should get to list as many fighters as you see fit, and then give everyone the chance to vote in up to half of them, and any fighter that gains 75% support gets in.


So if you choose ten fighters, everyone gets up to five votes, and if twenty people voted, any fighter with fifteen or more votes gets in. And as an emergency backstop, if no one gets 75%, then the fighter with the most votes gets in (you could break a tie).

 

Probably five to ten.

 

Great idea but I’m too busy at present.

 

Have you given any thoughts on who can vote? I'm just trying to think of how to avoid someone creating a bunch of alts or trolling.

 

I'm in.

Three is fine.

 

I do think the idea of a larger inaugural class makes sense and isn't a bad idea, though. Eight (one per original 8) perhaps?