Buchanan was a solid fighter, but Whitaker has too much of everything and just had a difficult style for most fighters to solve. Straight up style doesn't work against Pernell unless you are really tall, have very fast hands and a big punch, and even then it's not easy. Whitaker takes almost all the rounds and wins unanimously.
I have to agree with the consensus that Whitaker would take a decision , styles make fights and I don't think Ken's style would benefit against Sweet Pea, he'd have to apply pressure . I'd say somewhere along the lines of a 115-112 win. Ole Kenny ain't an easy out for any lightweight.
I'll probably go along with the consensus that Pea would win but he'd have to be on his A game. Buchanan has one of the most beautiful jabs ever seen and could hook off it quickly with plenty of power.He also had a granite chin and had bottle by the bucket full.
Like many first-rate Whitaker opponents, Buchanan has a bit of early success but Pea adjusts as he always did and runs the tables after about the fifth or sixth. A game effort from the Scot, and a clear decision for Whitaker.
Buchanan was great but Whitaker is just on another level here. Buchanan’s jab helps him early on and makes a good effort but Whitaker’s versatility and defense will come in to play where he outboxes Buchanan and win via decision 8-4.