I know I'm a mediocre scorer, and I also know why I'm a mediocre scorer (I accidentally give pity rounds and maybe a couple of rounds to fighters I like/predicted to win occasionally, though not on purpose). Some cards are really out there in the way I know I'd be scoring if I had no inhibition and some are always fair/balanced, based on a very consistent metric.
No one in here is a professional judge. We're not at the fights to hear the punches landing or close enough to see if either boxer is effected in some way. That's why there are so many "robberies" claimed. Sure, lots of us have seen hundreds or thousands of fights so the OBVIOUS decisions should be well, obvious, but even those fights are disputed. And many times it is again, obvious that people have a bone to pick with one guy or another, which should not happen as scores should be objective. No one in here is a good scorer. I'm including myself; I rarely post scores because at least I admit I DKSAScoring.
Pinoyprodigy Midnite Prowler George Crowcroft FranklinDallas Markus Florez99 All seem to score quite well. There are others who score well too but I always seem to agree with their scorecards
If I've got a dog in the fight that I really like I'm way to biased on the night. Add to that the alcohol consumed whilst watching doesn't help. Plus add in the fact I'm no fecking scoring expert anyway. I'm always fairer on the re-watch the next day though.... Usually.
Idk. I think if you're watching a fight on a big screen TV, with access to the slow motions, ect, its possible you've got a better view of the action than any single judge. Personally, I don't know why people put 'professional' judges on some sort of pedestal. How many times do they have to show either outright corruption or sheer incompetence? I'd take many boxing forums top scorers over many professional judges. Just imo though.
i like george and pinoy out of that list. just not familiar enough with the rests cards to be much help with them. i do think george sees more of the nuances in the fight, so its less of a connect count for him.
I almost always agree with @The Professor . A really good eye for what's happening in the ring. If only he could have this clarity with the real world.
PinoyProdigy : 6 George Crowcroft : 3 Inglis : 3 Professor: 3 IB : 2 CST80 : 1 Markus Florez : 1 FrankinDallas : 1 Midnight Prowler: 1 Chuck Norris : 1 Drama Show : 1 Drew 101 : 1 Drinquor : 1 F1ght3rz : 1
IntentionalButt Serge when he’s keeping score CST Pimp C is very good too Pinoy And then Shadow is obviously the worst by a factor of several Septillion
@CST80 @The Professor @Inglis_1 @Chuck Norris Are all pretty good but I'm great when sober. Unfortunately for me that's not often.