They are all highly intelligent posters. They are capable of explaining their thought processes well. But with the exceptions of Serge, the Professor, and Pimp C who I have no formed opinion on, the rest of your list is the list I would provide if asked who the worst scorers on the board were.
Personally, I think both fights were clear win’s respectively. The third fight was clearer for me as the early rounds in the first fight were quite subjective, it depends on what you liked. GGG swept the middle rounds which won him the fight. In the third fight Canelo swept most the rounds and GGG came on and took the late ones but wasn’t enough
I tend to glance through a couple pages of scores to get an idea of how a fight is going rather than rely on any one poster.
I'm not actually interested in who the objectively best scorers are (if such a thing exists lol) just who the forum feel are. I just need prominent and popular scorers to use as examples later, and the best way to do that is to get the forums vote. My own selections wouldn't be as useful in the examples I'll be doing.
Pinoy is good most of the time, like me. But also like me, he turns in some crazy biased scorecards, usually when they involve a Filipino fighter. So he has a few blind spots as well. But usually because he turns them in on quite obscure matches, he flies under the radar, where I'm willing to fly in the face of popular sentiment on huge matches, in massive RBR's.
Yes, that's the point, that the first fight was much closer on a RBR basis than the 3rd fight. Not only were the early rounds "subjective" (by that you surely mean Canelo "arguably" won them) but also the late rounds as well. Canelo "arguably" won 1-3 and 10-12. And then we have rounds 4-6 which were very tight as well. When you say GGG swept the middle rounds, you gotta be specific. 4-6 were also very "subjective", those were far closer and more arguable for Canelo than rounds 1-8 were for GGG in the 3rd fight. Scoring the first fight for Canelo is more reasonable than scoring GGG won the 3rd fight, that we can agree on.
I don't know. It's been a long time since I actually paid attention to Pinoy's scores. I just know that I'd hear people jacking him off on more than one occasion when his score was dog****. Gradually, I came to disregard almost every scorer in the RBRs because they were all over the place and everyone insisted that if someone had just as bad a scorecard as they did that they were the GOAT. You cannot figure out what actually happened in a fight from our RBR threads. They are really more sources of camaraderie where we can watch a fight with friends, make fun of David Diamante's hair, and **** on national anthems.