P4P rankings

Tyson Fury

Would have Beterbiev , Bivol and Inoue above him

 

How does Crawford get onto a P4P list? His best win is Viktor Postol, his resume is Grade A garbage. I hope this is your list because it's trash, or please name and shame the publication.

 

Usyk
Inoue
Fury
Spence
Bivol
Canelo
Haney
Charlo
Crawford
BeterbieV

 

1.Usyk
2.Inoue
3.Bivol
4.Beterbiev
5.Canelo
6.Crawford
7.Spence
8.Juan Manuel Marquez
9.Lomachenko
10.Jemell Charlo
11.Fury
12.Taylor
13.Stevenson
14.Haney
15.Fulton

 

May be in the minority here but I don't see what Crawford and Spence have done to get on any top 10 p4p list, the only reason they are spoken about so often is because they could fight each other to establish the top guy at 147, but outside of that both of their bodies of work leave a lot to be desired, particularly Spence if you ask me, Crawford goes a little further on the eye test imo but I don't believe either of them have done enough to be rated as highly as they both are

 

How is Fury #1 p4p? Usyk is the unified champ and was the undisputed cruiserweight.

Usyk arguably beat the better opponent with the better resume.

 

Putting Tank in a p4p list always makes me scratch my head tbh

 

Exactly. IMO Fury’s is arguably even in the top 10.

 

Juan Manuel Marquez????

1) Usyk







2)Bivol
3)Beterbiev
4)Inoue
5) Canelo
6)Lomachenko
7) Fury
8) Plant
9)GGG
10) Crawford

 

I have Usyk as #1 and tbh that is not arguable to me, but I don't see the case that Usyk had the better opponent wins at heavyweight. Wilder and Champ Waldo > post Ruiz Joshua.

He's clearly P4P the better fighter, but I'm not sure he's the better heavyweight. Prey we find out though

 

Plant isn’t in the top 50, let alone the top 10…

 

1.Usyk 2.Inoue 3.Bivol 4.Berterbiev 5.Clenelo 6.Spence 7.Fury 8.Lomachenko 9.Haney 10.Crawford

summat like that

 

P4P = Ignore size advantage of people like Fury, or style of fighter like Usyk since he wouldn't have to be fighting bigger men?
= Assume how they'd fight at same size?
Or just who does their thing best? Because that's not then skill to pound ratio. And you couldn't put a Fury on P4P list unless he has so much more skill than a Usyk, it's not even balanced by the size difference per lb.

Weird.