Rank the Following Current Fighters by Their Historical Legacy As of Now

Ie, if they retired today, are they? All time great? Hall of Famer? Elite? Not even that? If they're all time great, where do they rank? Top 100? Top 50? Top 20? Higher?

No need to answer them all, but the following are people I see listed as pound for pounders:

Oleksandr Usyk
Naoya Inoue
Terence Crawford
Errol Spence
Canelo Alvarez
Dmitry Bivol
Vasily Lomachenko
Josh Taylor
Jermell Charlo
Juan Francisco Estrada
Kazuto Ioka
Kenshiro Teraji
Roman Gonzalez
Shakur Stevenson
Artur Beterbiev
Tyson Fury

 

Too many peeps ffs

Top echelon as of NOW:

Inoue
Usyk
Fury

2nd tier as of NOW:

Crawford
Canelo
Jermell
Spence
Loma

3rd tier as of NOW:

Beterbiev
Bivol

4th tier as of NOW:

Josh Taylor

Dont know enough about Ioka, Estrada, Gonzalez, and Teraji. Shakur is hardly just starting out..

 

Oleksandr Usyk - ATG
Naoya Inoue - HOF on the way to ATG
Terence Crawford - HOF
Errol Spence - On the way to HOF
Canelo Alvarez - ATG
Dmitry Bivol - No where yet but possible HOF
Vasily Lomachenko - HOF
Josh Taylor - None of the above.
Jermell Charlo - None of the above
Juan Francisco Estrada - HOF - Possible ATG
Kazuto Ioka - HOF - ATG
Kenshiro Teraji - HOF
Roman Gonzalez - ATG
Shakur Stevenson - No where yet but with big potential
Artur Beterbiev - No where yet but possible HOF
Tyson Fury - HOF

 

Josh Taylor, Ioka, Kenshiro, and Estrada don’t belong on this list. They’re all really good but they’re not on the same level as the rest.

 

Jermell and Taylor will probably be HOF for becoming undisputed.

 

Estradas resume is Miles better than Jermell Charlo.

 

LOL I meant Jermell and Taylor.

 

Ffs Ioka and Estrada not on the level of Jermell Charlo. The stupidity on this forum never ceases to amaze me.

 

Yeah, whoops, I meant rate, not rank.

 

I feel like Ioka in particular gets a lot of disrespect. Both of his losses are cons, he's a four division champ who was unified at 105, and if you look at his resume, it's very good:

Tanaka (3 div champ)
Yaegashi (3 div champ)
Nietes (4 div champ)
Alvarado (light flyweight champ for four years)
Draw vs Franco (Super fly champ for 3 years so far)
Robbery loss vs Ruenroeng (flyweight champion with good resume)
Sithmorseng (Minimum-weight champ for a year)
Reveco (WBA flyweight champion)
Hernandez (WBC flyweight champion)
Sithsamerchai (WBC minimum-weight champion for four years)

Also, Ioka has been fighting at the top level for a very long time. He won his first world title in 2011.

 

I hope you're wrong but you're probably right. I think it should be the defenses of the undisputed title which makes a fighter HOF-worthy not just becoming undisputed.

 

Oleksandr Usyk : ATG: No. 1 Cruiser of all time. If he was to retire tomorrow unfortunately the best I could rate him at HW would be top 30 all time because we haven't seen enough.
Naoya Inoue ATG, best japanese fighter of all time.
Terence Crawford HOF, Top 5 at 140.
Errol Spence Elite Welter in his prime, not anywhere near ATG but the HOF is BS, so he's probably in already.
Canelo Alvarez ATG with added beef, HOF only beef free.
Dmitry Bivol HOF, got my doubts he's ATG yet.
Vasily Lomachenko ATG.
Josh Taylor HOF, Top 10 140.
Jermell Charlo HOF
Juan Francisco Estrada HOF
Kazuto Ioka HOF
Kenshiro Teraji HOF
Roman Gonzalez ATG
Shakur Stevenson HOF
Artur Beterbiev ATG Top 10 at LHW but I am biased here, he's my fav fighter.
Tyson Fury Borderline elite HW.
I would like to expand on my answers when not pressed for time.

 

Without question, takes a lot less to get in nowadays.