Post your TOP 10 P4P list

Bud
Inoue
Usyk
Canelo
Teo
Haney
Loma
Jermell
Tank
Beterbiev

No idea how Bivol is breaking into these lists tbh

 

1) Naoya Inoue
2) Oleksandr Usyk
3) Terence Crawford
4) Dmitry Bivol
5) Artur Beterbiev
6) Vasiliy Lomachenko
7) Clenelo Alvaroids
8) Juan Francisco Estrada
9) Kazuto Ioka
10) Tyson Fury

 

Crawford
Usyk
Inoue
Canelo
Beterbiev
Teofimo
Lomachenko
Bivol
(from here not sure)
Estrada & Haney perhaps. Or even Shakur in place of Haney, because I really didn’t think Haney beat Lomachenko.

No particular order for the top 3.

 

1.crawford
2.inoue
3.usyk
4.bivol
5.canelo
6.teo
7.jermell
8.beterbiev
9.haney
10.shakur

 

1 Inoue
2 Crawford
3 Usyk
4 Bivol
5 Alvarez
6 Beterbiev
7 Estrada
8 Lopez
9 Haney
10 Fury

I also like you thought Lomachenko beat Haney but he officially lost, so I have to take him out of the top 10 based on that even though I don't want to.

Fury I do not like him at all but I think he deserves a spot in the 10.

Estrada seems to be forgotten about by most fans and I don't know why ? He has one of the best resumes in the last few years.

 

Crawford
Inoue
Usyk


The rest..

 

Why not ? Bivol has 2 back to back stand out wins/performances over Canelo who was P4P top 3, and Ramirez who was 44-0. Bivol won both of these fights in a very impressive manner, not to mention Bivol has 10 title defences in which he has won all of them pretty convincingly.

I can't see how logically you can't have Bivol in the top 10 ?

 

1- Inoue
2- Crawford
3- Usyk

4- Canelo
5- Beterbiev
6- Bivol
7- Fury

8- Lopez
9- Haney
10- Lomachenko

 

1.Crawford
2.Inoue
3.Usyk
4.Canelo
5.Bivol
6.Beterbiev
7.Estrada
8.Stevenson
9.Lopez
10.Loma/Haney

I rank Stevenson higher than others but I think he’s the most skilled fighter in the best division right now.

 

The amount of people who have Lomachenko in their top 10 is baffling

 

1. Spence Jr

(I'm joking.)

1. Usyk
2. Canelo
3. Bivol
4. Beterbiev
5. Crawford
6. Tank
7. Fury
8. Inoue
9. Haney
10. Jermell

 

Thanks for replying to me, as I wanted to sound off on this NPC behaviour-

No one's actually going over this pick in their minds, they're just going by Ring, and as much as I love Ring, they're dead wrong on this

Bivol has no standout performance against an elite 175er in or around their prime. There's no Beterbiev or Gvozdyk or anything. He has wins over B-listers and his biggest win to date is against a man... coming up. A 168er. A small 168er. I don't think Bivol would've beaten Canelo were they the same dimensions. Canelo cherrypicked Kovalev, who was having an Indian Summer at the time, and when he fought a legit light heavyweight he was exposed. Anything above 168 is merely raiding territory for Canelo - 168 is his cap

So... Bivol's lone standout performance is beating a guy well out of his natural weight class, in which he used his superior size, dimensions and punch resistance to full effect, and other than that he's never unified, fought weak WBA mandatories, has-been light heavyweights, continental-level guys and people with heavily padded records. Zurdo's 44-0 means about as much as Munguia's 40whatever

The only thing going for Bivol is the eye-test, and as Saturday proved, as if this even needed proving, the eye-test is heavily influenced by the level of competition in front of you

Putting Bivol over guys like Teo who have gone up weight classes and fought elite opposition at every turn is shameful. Joey Maxim is historically regarded as a relatively weak light heavyweight champion. This dude didn't become some P4P monster overnight for beating a Ray Robinson who was winning amateur titles at featherweight

And look, I prefer Beterbiev to Bivol, but I honestly think Bivol would show him levels + youth should they fight. But P4P needs some kind of deep thinking or at least consistent logic going into it

 

1. Inoue
2. Crawford
3. Beterbiev
4. Usyk
5. Teofimo
6. Fury
7. Bivol
8. Canelo
9. Tank Davis
10. Jermell Charlo

Haney and Loma are both overrated to high heaven

Shakur is good but doesn’t have any standout wins or achievements yet

Estrada is yesterday’s news