With Usyk having already beaten Joshua to take all his belts the other two standout fighters of this era are Fury and Wilder. If Usyk was to beat Fury and take his belt to become the first Heavyweight to go Undisputed in the four belt era and then went on to defeat Wilder is this enough for Usyk to be classed as a Heavyweight ATG having then won all the belts and cleaned out the division of his main rivals ?
At Cruiserweight yes. Heavyweight is a work in progress ATM. I'll reserve me judgment after what John Fury and Teddy Atlas say about this last performance.
His HW resume: is Witherspoon, Chisora, Joshua, Joshua, Dubois. A gate keeper A top man in the division. Two times. And a borderline top 10 contender. He needs Fury he beats him. Yes
He literally has only a handful of fights at heavyweight, and only one opponent who was in the top 5. He's definitely an ATG at cruiser, but he needs many more fights against top heavyweight opponents before anyone can ask that question.
I don't understand what you're saying here. Who wouldn't have those names on their ATG heavyweights list?
He's an ATG for what he has achieved at both CW and HW Undisputed champ at CW in just 15 fights Three belt unified champ at HW in just 19 fights Winning, defending, and unifying all his world titles in his opponent's backyards when some of the greats never dared do that once or categorically refused to He won 7 of the 8 world titles in 19 fights at two separate weights
Undeniably, he is all-time great fighter but how anyone can say he is an all-time great heavyweight is beyond me. He doesn't have enough fights at the weight and he certainly doesn't have enough quality wins to have earned all-time great status.
Sure, but they also had extensive resumes against the best of the heavyweight division. All I'm saying is it's too early to say the same about Usyk, he at the very least needs to beat Fury, Wilder, Zhang, or a few other top 10 heavyweights before we have that discussion. There's no doubt about his ATG status at cruiser, though, he was king of an absolutely stacked division.