OK - Is Manny Pac Top 15 of All Time?

Any discussion w/ Manny's ATG standing should result in him being considered for the top 15-20. I would not argue any placement, even if someone says top ten. Manny was that great.

 

Most people and aficionados got Floyd top 5, I got him at 3 and that’s irrefutable

 

No one actually does little girl....

 

Do you think ATG lists are meaningless like P4P lists? Same thing — everyone's is different. Be consistent.

 

It’s undeniable Floyd was the best fighter of his era and that’s why Manny ducked him forever

Floyd proceeded to completely annihilate him in their fight and won 10 rounds

Should have Kod him too if he was younger

 

are you f*ckin serious??? P4P and ATG list are NOT remotely the same thing. Good grief cannot believe you actually believe that. Wow... You've exposed QUITE a bit with that one single line.

 

No he's not.

 

Both lists are subjective, vary by person, media outlet, or fighter. The only difference is one deals with the present time in boxing and the other deals with the entire history of the sport. ATG lists, which AGAIN, are subjective and vary, are no different than P4P lists.

Serious question, how many head injuries have you suffered in your life?

 

He is top 5 minimum.

 

All the ranking are subjective FFS. That's why all orgs have different rankings.
Go bother someone else dude. You take P4P WAAY TOO SERIOUSLY. You get pissed and angry over this silly stuff and I don't care to debate someone so oddly invested in a P4P list. I think someone at the Bscene message board is talking smack about them. Run long lil doggy...

 

I'm just calling out your stupid ass for your inconsistency. I realize that the logical points I set forth escape your comprehension, but just know that you're an idiot and we're good.

Thanks, little buddy.

 

Agree. Pacquiao's body of work is the best since Duran.

 

That's a different thing... Even you know that. You're just pussyhurt trying to save face.

 

the top 15 p4p is really stacked. I would say very few of the top 15 are in there "comfortably." Whenever I make a top 15 atg p4p list there are only a few boxers that always make it in. If we choose this to mean "comfortably" then I would say no.

I would say off the top of my head top 35 is the lowest Pacquiao can be. If you don't have him at least within the top 35 then something went wrong during your list.