who's the greatest Asian Boxer alltime?

He could be, probably wont. There is not a single HOF candidate on the horizon for Inoue.
And at a similar age, Manny was already fighting at 147. Having beaten several HOF´s.

Inoue has one, an old Donaire. The gap in opponents quality is too big. Inoue would have to move to 135 to find someone who might get into the HOF.

 

All wrong
Ali Raymi put some respect on God's lions killers name

 

Inoue a great fighter but like you said Manny @ 30 was fighting above 130.Had a colossal trilogy and quadrology with fellow greats.I dunno where they get this inoue fought amazing atg talent from..

 

Manny Pacquiao

 

Pacquiao for now but as already mentioned the book is not closed on Inoue yet .

 

Pac

 

The blind will follow the blind

 

Zhilei Zhang, probably knocks pac out in 1 round.

 

Shinji Takehara

 

Uchiyama

 

I'm a huge Harada fan but I don't think there's a compelling case for him being over Pacquiao.

 

Inoue does have himself to blame there a bit.
115 had Gonzales had Estrada, but Inoue skipped the division.

 

Manny, but Inoue can surpass this. That is still open.

 

Manny Pacquiao clearly. Fighting Harada is currently the second best Asian boxer but Naoya Inoue could very well surpass him when he retires. Pac set the bar very high and it's gonna be hard for any fighter to come close to what he achieved. The most Inoue can do is to continue to dominate and perhaps go for one more undisputed run at 126.

 

Pac stands several head and shoulders above everybody for the last and probably next 50 years. This really isnt a hard discussion