Jersey Joe Walcott vs Roy Jones Jr

Walcott bigger and better.

 

I agree that he was bigger

 

Walcott wipes him out. RJJ would have no chance against an ATG like that.

 

Prime Roy at what kind of weight?

 

Looking through RJJ's resume I see no ATG scalps that could match up to Walcott. Jones' best work was done at the lighter weights. Mediocre resume at the higher weights lets be honest.

 

JJW pounded the s**t out of Marciano in their first fight in 1952...do you see Roy Jones pounding the s**t out of Rocky Marciano?...me neither...Marciano breaks Jones in half...Walcott TKO over Jones...

 

Jersey Joe beats him by ko.
Walcott s power is underrated by many, putting Marciano, Louis and Charles down is impressive.
At some point Jersey Joe gets Jones out of there.

 

Joe has losses to guys Roy's size that were slower with less power and less mobile.

I too would favor the best Jersey Joe over Roy, but I can't say he'd have "no" chance. It's hard to gauge Joe's best because his prime was peppered with wins and losses. I will say Joe's best wins and scalps dwarf Roy's best wins

 

Those don't count because he wasn't at his best. That's how things work around here.

 

I did also concede that I still favored him and Jersey Joe's best wins dwarfed Roy's best wins

 

Thats because RJJ fought at LHW. But during Walcotts time the HWs were bloated LHWs. This is the one era of HW Roy Jones would be a normal size HW. If Maxim could fight Walcott close every time its tough to see Walcott beating RJJ on points. And he'd probably have to win it on points because besides the Charles KO which he was handidly winning beforehand he seldom stopped his top opponents. He did not have a major stoppage in the entire 1940s despite no shortage of quality opponents. He KO'd Elmer Ray.....in 1937 when Ray was 8-8. So I don't know where people get this confidence that Walcott is going to KO RJJ. Walcott knocked down Marciano...and then let him stick around the whole fight.

RJJ fought once at HW and at CW in his 40s. He wasn't really trying to compile a resume at the higher weights. That shouldn't be held against him especially against HWs from the smallest era. When Roy was at his peak the HW champ was Lennox Lewis who was 6 ft 6 and weighed nearly 250. And a few years after winning the WBA belt off Ruiz that belt would be held by Valuev a 300+ pounder. Almost that entire generation of HWs would be at LHW if they were fighting in RJJs time.

 

Roy Jones jr! An unmatched talent, the modern day Boxer could do nothing against him, histories best wouldn’t have a clue what to do with him
Just too fast in every department
His bombs would land as they always did at his best and the marauding Walcott would be stopped unable to land anything
Jones footwork and reflexes are still unmatched
Walcott did nothing spectacular
He was ok in a fight but Jones’s hit and not get hit was unbeatable