Not really. You don't think Donaire in 2019/2022 is a higher 1-shot-KO risk than Golovkin in 2017/18? Aight pookie.
My point is he still had wins it's not like he lost all his later fights. Come back to this thread when both are retired and we can revist this topic. Who are the fighters that inoue can fight that can make him surpass canelo? There's no p4p elite talent for him to fight at 122 or 126. I predicted inoue would destroy nery months ago who isn't a great fighter. Give me p4p elite guys that he can beat or face to raise his stock. They don't exist at 122 or 126.
I didn’t say that, donaire has better one punch ko power but GGG was the better and more complete fighter than Donaire. He was also undefeated.
The only P4P guys Canelo has fought are, in order, Shane Mosley (shot to bits and old as dirt, hollow win), Mayweather (got taken to school), Miguel Cotto (never belonged at MW, very far past his prime, still gave Canelo fits and is still his best win even though it's not a good win), GGG (past prime, still beat Canelo twice), Kovalev (past his prime, Canelo made him agree to a shorter camp so he'd have a worse weight cut, and was an alcoholic, hollow win), Bivol (schooled again) and Jermell (who showed up inactive, fat, ran the whole night, and only showed up to get a pay check, dragged up 2 divisions). All in that is 4-4, which I wouldn't exactly call consistent.
My take is sound give me the lomas or rigos who are elite top 10 p4p boxers that are on Inoue's resume. They're nowhere to be found and level of comp has to be factored in when assessing historical greatness. Don't get mad at me because you can't handle the truth.
/QUOTE="Pimp C, post: 22851188, member: 2008"The point is he didn't lose to ggg twice he's 2-0-1 against him. P4p list are a measuring stick and are used when assessing greatness. There are no great fighters on inoues resume with the exception of donaire period. Canelo's resume is littered with great fighters which is why he will be remembered as great and ranked higher when it's all said and done.[/QUOTE] by who? You and flat earther Shadow and that drunk Isal? I also like the consistency cause when it's a bad decision like Canelo VS Ggg 1 you go by the official decision but when it's Pac VS Marquez it's Marquez was robbed and the official decisions don't matter then again when it's Pac VS Horn another clear robbery you again go for the official decision. Consistency mate concistency...
All of these guys with exception of a shot Mosley you listed are better than the guys that inoue is beating.
Ranked higher by who? You and flat earther Shadow and that drunk Isal? I also like the consistency cause when it's a bad decision like Canelo VS Ggg 1 you go by the official decision but when it's Pac VS Marquez it's Marquez was robbed and the official decisions don't matter then again when it's Pac VS Horn another clear robbery you again go for the official decision. Consistency mate concistency...[/QUOTE] I liked Canelo when he fought ggg that was the first fight I cheered for him and have been a fan ever since pbf doesn't factor into me being a fan of his. I scored ggg-canelo 1 a draw so I don't know what you're talking about here.
I liked Canelo when he fought ggg that was the first fight I cheered for him and have been a fan ever since pbf doesn't factor into me being a fan of his. I scored ggg-canelo 1 a draw so I don't know what you're talking about here.[/QUOTE] If you had it a draw why are you going by the official decision? You dont do the same with Pac vs Marquez .
If you had it a draw why are you going by the official decision? You dont do the same with Pac vs Marquez .[/QUOTE] Which pac-jmm fight are you referring to?
Which pac-jmm fight are you referring to?[/QUOTE] The ones Pac didnt lost like the draw and the two wins.
You not lying bro. Inoue and Tank are my 2 fave fighters but both have not had that career defining win yet. It’s unfortunate because Inoue could have had Chocolatito and Estrada in his resume and no one would be able to question his greatness.
The ones Pac didnt lost like the draw and the two wins.[/QUOTE] I don't have a problem with the first fight being a draw but I think pac probably edged it.
I don't have a problem with the first fight being a draw but I think pac probably edged it.[/QUOTE] You just shutting his assumptions down