Recently I've been rewatching the fights and honestly it's one of the greatest trilogies I've ever seen each fight was an amazing display of both technique and excitement but I'm curious how others scored them. Personally I thought Chocolatito won the first and second but lost the third but I'm wondering how others scored the fights. Would love to hear your thoughts!
Gonzalez-Estrada I Round 1 Estrada 10-9 Round 2 Estrada 10-9 Round 3 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 4 Estrada 10-9 Round 5 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 6 Gonzalez 10-9 Close Round 7 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 8 Gonzalez 10-9 Close Round 9 Estrada 10-9 Round 10 Estrada 10-9 Close Round 11 Estrada 10-9 Close Round 12 Estrada 10-9 115-113 Estrada Gonzalez-Estrada II Round 1 Estrada 10-9 Round 2 Estrada 10-9, close Round 3 Estrada 10-9, close Round 4 Estrada 10-9 Round 5 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 6 Estrada 10-9 Round 7 Estrada 10-9 Round 8 Estrada 10-9, close Round 9 Estrada 10-9 Round 10 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 11 Estrada 10-9, close Round 12 Gonzalez 10-9 117-111 Estrada Gonzalez-Estrada III Round 1 Estrada 10-9 Round 2 Estrada 10-9 Round 3 Estrada 10-9 Round 4 Estrada 10-9 Round 5 Estrada 10-9 Round 6 Estrada 10-9 Round 7 Estrada 10-9 Round 8 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 9 Estrada 10-9 Round 10 Gonzalez 10-9 Round 11 Estrada 10-9 Round 12 Estrada 10-9 118-110 Estrada
The second one, on the RBR, I said 116-112 and 115-113 are fine as well. But I've never understood all of the cries that it was a robbery. I found all of that talk bordering on mass hysteria.
I don't have a scorecard for the 1st fight. Roman Gonzalez vs Juan Francisco Estrada 2 1 Estrada 2 Gonzalez 3 Estrada 4 Gonzalez 5 Gonzalez 6 Estrada 7 Estrada 8 Estrada 9 Gonzalez 10 Gonzalez 11 Estrada 12 Gonzalez 114-114 Draw Juan Francisco Estrada vs Roman Gonzalez 3 1 Estrada 2 Estrada 3 Gonzalez 4 Estrada 5 Estrada 6 Estrada 7 Gonzalez 8 Gonzalez 9 Gonzalez 10 Gonzalez 11 Estrada 12 Estrada 115-113 Estrada
First fight I had Chocolatito winning by a clear margin 8-4 or 7-5. Second fight I still had Chocolatito winning 7-5 but have no problem with a draw. Third fight Gallo clearly edged it 7-5. These two were definitely made for each other and their rivalry will go down as one of the best in boxing history.
This is how I scored the third fight. Round 1 - 10-9 Estrada Round 2 - 10-9 Estrada Round 3 - 10-9 Estrada Close Round 4 - 10-9 Estrada Round 5 - 10-9 Estrada Round 6 - 10-9 Estrada Round 7 - 10-9 Gonzalez Round 8 - 10-9 Gonzalez Round 9 - 10-9 Gonzalez Round 10 - 10-9 Gonzalez Very Close Round 11 - 10-9 Estrada Round 12 - 10-9 Estrada Very Close Estrada 116-112
I really don't see how you scored the second so wide here's what I had it Roman 'Chocolatito' Gonzalez vs. Juan Francisco Estrada II Round 1 10-9 Estrada Round 2 10-9 Gonzalez Round 3 10-9 Estrada Round 4 10-9 Gonzalez Round 5 10-9 Gonzalez Round 6 10-9 Estrada (close) Round 7 10-9 Estrada Round 8 10-9 Gonzalez Round 9 10-9 Gonzalez (close) Round 10 10-9 Gonzalez Round 11 10-9 Estrada (close) Round 12 10-9 Gonzalez 115-113 Gonzalez I can see it 7-5 Gonzalez 6-6 or 7-5 Estrada but I think you gave way too many Gonzalez rounds to Estrada and gave him all the close rounds.