the what fights did you watch today\scorecard thread.

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Mantequilla, Nov 20, 2009.


  1. Dynamicpuncher

    Dynamicpuncher Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    15,568
    32,411
    Jan 14, 2022
    Good work Scar if you ever want another decent Norris fight to watch his fight vs Golota is another example of Norris doing well and holding his own vs a big Heavyweight in a entertaining fight.

    No one talks about Orlin Norris but he was an above average Cruiserweight champion and held his own in the Heavyweight division beat Page, McCall, Tucker.
     
    Jel, scartissue and Fireman Fred like this.
  2. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,384
    12,743
    Mar 2, 2006
    Michael Brodie v In Jin Chi I (vacant featherweight title)

    Round 1: 10-8 Chi (Chi's round and Brodie deducted a point for an unintentional headbutt)
    Round 2: 10-8 Chi (scores a knockdown)
    Round 3: 10-9 Brodie
    Round 4: 10-9 Brodie
    Round 5: 10-9 Chi
    Round 6: 10-9 Brodie
    Round 7: 10-9 Brodie
    Round 8: 10-10 Even
    Round 9: 10-9 Chi
    Round 10: 10-9 Chi
    Round 11: 10-9 Chi
    Round 12: 10-10 Even

    Total: 116-112 Chi (actual scores: 114-112 Chi and 2 scores of 113-113 for a majority draw)

    Man, you have to break this fight down in 2 parts. The actual match, which was exceptional, and then the complete hash-job the officials performed.

    Regarding the fight: fantastic! Brodie was so strong and should have stuck to his strong jab to move Chi to the ropes where he performed well. But Chi had other ideas and would fire back where his sharp hooks and bottomless tank took Brodie's measure. I believe I gave Brodie credit for everything and British announcers Glenn McCrory and Ian Darke had comparable cards to mine, so I was somewhat amazed at the closeness of the scores.

    The officials: They sucked! What an unprofessional ending from a set of WBC/British officials. For one, the referee apparently deducted a point from Brodie, which was clearly accidental as they both were moving in and where Brodie was the one actually cut. We didn't even know this until the TV cameras moved in while they were screwing up their cards and saw the point deduction which no one knew about. Then tallying the cards up took forever. I think they would have tallied it up quicker with an abacus. Moreover, even with Jose Sulaiman jumping in and adding things up, they still screwed it up and announced a majority decision for Chi and even had the poor guy wearing the championship belt before taking it away a half hour later when they stated that the judge who had it 113-112 for Chi added wrong and made it 113-113 for a majority draw. What a mess of an ending to a great fight.
     
    Jel, Dynamicpuncher and Fireman Fred like this.
  3. Jel

    Jel Obsessive list maker Full Member

    7,834
    13,128
    Oct 20, 2017
    Hi Scar, here’s my card from a while back and I had it similar to you.


    Michael Brodie v Injin Chi 1

    1 8-10 (wild opener. Chi and Brodie bumped heads - Broadie docked a point. Bad gash on top of Brodie’s head. Chi rocks Brodie towards end of round)
    2 8-10 (Chi puts Brodie down)
    3 10-9
    4 10-9 (Brodie into the fight now)
    5 9-10 (close)
    6 10-9
    7 10-9 (Brodie boxing well. Good back and forth action)
    8 10-9
    9 9-10
    10 9-10
    11 9-10 (close)
    12 9-10
    Broadie 111-115 Chi
     
    scartissue likes this.
  4. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,384
    12,743
    Mar 2, 2006
    Jel, we were clearly watching the same fight, unlike the judges.
     
    Jel likes this.
  5. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    113,044
    48,170
    Mar 21, 2007
    Juan Fracisco Estrada MD12 Roman Gonzalez

    Quite the size difference for these two when you see them face to face, it looks like more than an inch. The end (hopefully) of the great sub 118lbs rivalry of this generation. Estrada gets his usual fast start, mostly left handed but the vareity - lead left hook to the beltline (against a world class opponent??), left jabs, lead left uppercut, cuffing left hook off the jab, that's a power-jab. Gonzalez has high gloves, contests the space, throws almost nothing in the first round, this always confused me. Why measure guns or preview a guy that you have shared 24 rounds with? It is his way, but it cost him the fight here, arguably, this isn't round 25, it seems like round 1.

    Roman does start to sneak in little punches in the second, nothing like the flowing combinations that made him famous against the odds and godlike as a pugilist but he's starting to make a measure of his man in a losing effort. The third feels like the end of the phony war. Estrada is moving back and to the right, while Roman dips in behind his gloves and throws two-handed for the first time. Estrada does well left-handed off that back foot and wins the first half of the round but Gonzalez catches Estrada a little disorganised on the backfoot in the second half and improvises around that, lading good punches on the ropes - referee calls time out after a clash of heads and spills Roman's momentum, he was right though - i think a good right handed punch after that break maybe just nicks the third round for Estrada.

    The fourth and fifth feel like disasters for Gonzalez to me. Estrada has fathomed him while moving away and has added the right hand to the offensive quilt, Roman now has two sides to deal with. Weirdly this might free him up a bit to press because the reality isn't as destructive as the virtual threat, but he's being out-hit and he's 35 - he's relying upon his superior economy paying dividends early enough to help get him into a box seat against an opponent who is out-fighting him going away and has proven himself Roman's near equal inside. Estrada has as close to complete control as you can have against a fighter like Roman, he is boxing up and down wide and narrow, so he's lopping over a wide hook and following it up with a narrow uppercut, he's bludgeoning and he's precision, he's both across the board. It's horrible. Defensively, Estrada is so old-fashioned in that he likes to put his head where he feels his opponent can't hit it, sparring learning not drilled learning. That might be behind gloves but it also might just be stooping, something it feels like Roman should be able to take advantage of but often he can't. Estrada's positioning is generally good enough to get away with this.

    Gonzalez took a bigger thrashing in the corner than he did during the fifth round; they tell him he's losing big. He is, 5-0 on my card, a disaster. Now here is a little spoiler: last time I scored this fight I didn't give Estrada another round until the 12th. Estrada definitely wins the first minute of the round, jabbing, moving away, dusting the left hand up and down - clearly Estrada wins the first minute. The sections of the match Roman has won however, all seemed to be along the ropes and Gonzalez does actually win the second minute, by a hair, fighting him in the middle fo the ring, very accurate with the left hand, defensively sound. It felt like Estrada was being pushed back rather than moving back to cede himself space to punch. The sixth is very close - it should be scored even really, but Gonzalez was coming forwards and he landed some nice one-twos in the final twenty seconds. I don't think you can score the sixth "wrong" and i'd give it to Gonzalez close. I think that he also wins the seventh close, another debateable round and the better punches were probably landed by Estrada but Gonzalez is really enjoying his time along the ropes now - Estrada looks to be resting there rather than waiting for his charge. Total change of the tone in the Roman corner.

    In the eighth, Gonzalez scores on-twos along the ropes and he's cutting the ring beautifully, actually stepping out in front of Estrada, reading the ring well enough to know he can't go left and getting in ahead of him. This is Roman's best first minute in the fight and he wins that first minute, maybe for the first time. The kettle is on. Straight right, left uppercut is the key two-piece that wins him the final minute - Estrada is still getting his licks in, including a double left-hook up and down that takes the breath away, but the first clear Gonzalez round has been posted. Estrada looks tight in the 8th and Gonzalez gives him the volume along the ropes. Estrada is not gone - he might even win the last minute of the 9th - but he is number two across the board in the ring. Gonzalez is less concerned with being hit, that's how he's taken over. It doesn't bother him. Estrada tightens up a bit, starts arm-punching a little rather than boxing those smooth combos we love him for, he seeks to touch rather than bury. He gets hammered by one-twos in the tenth before Roman - finally - opens up with seven eight punch combos in two spells. Where tf does he get this from? He's ancient by the standards of the weight-class and has just taken it from the younger man in the second half of the fight. I have it 5-5 after ten.

    Estrada forces himself into holding the line in the eleventh, his feet are higher, he hits back more - Gonzalez still pockets it, and it's not that debatable for me. Estrada hits a hard brake in the twelfth though, it's wonderful to see, first he is throwing an extra punch, it seems, in his defensive flurries, second, he is ready to hold the line when he feels like he has position which probably buys him a couple of scoring punches, third, he stays off those ropes. He circles tight, he risks an awful lot more and it pays off - I thought he nicked a storm of a round to earn the draw on my card. Gonzalez two years too old to win that wonderful round.

    Estrada:1,2,3,4,5,12.
    Roman:6,7,8,9,10,11.

    114-114
    Official: 115-113, 116-112, 114-114.

    I think 114-114 is the optimal card, but if someone has to win it, Estrada is probably the right man. His rally in the twelfth was incredible, a champion's round, but more than that, while the 3rd and 7th are arguable, the sixth is a coin toss - I gave Roman two of those three rounds. So if it has to go one way, it should go to Estrada.
     
  6. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,384
    12,743
    Mar 2, 2006
    Salvador Sanchez v Rocky Garcia (featherweight title)

    Round 1: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 2: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 3: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 4: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 5: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 6: 10-10 Even
    Round 7: 9-9 Even (Sanchez' round but docked a point for a low blow)
    Round 8: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 9: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 10: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 11: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 12: 10-10 Even
    Round 13: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 14: 10-9 Sanchez
    Round 15: 10-10 Even

    Total: 149-138 Sanchez (actual scores: 147-138, 146-141 and 147-141 all for Sanchez)

    Garcia was a good, tough fighter but was second best in everything but heart. I remember this fight and was amazed when Rocky got this assignment as he was really nothing but a grade above prospect. But he did put in a gutsy effort. I believe I gave him everything I could for this bout. He really never mounted an attack against Sanchez, but counter when Sanchez came forward. But that aside, I did enjoy the contest.
     
    Mike Cannon and Fireman Fred like this.
  7. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    113,044
    48,170
    Mar 21, 2007
    Jesse Rodrigeuz UD12 Carlos Cuadras

    Rodriguez does not get anything like enough love for this performance. It was amazing. Cuadras was right in the Gonzalez/Wangek/Estrada mix and Rodriguez, a prospect, takes this fight on no notice. Outrageous. He ends up a strap holder at 115 before he was looking for it and ends up dropping back down to 112 to win a title before stepping up to 115 again. Beast. Cuadras starts the stronger of the two with those foraging , varied one-twos. Rodriguez looks completely unrattled though, establishes his jab to the body and brings the exchanges a little lower generally. The second is an important round because we see Rodriguez bank a round before the defining even of I think the third - Rodriguez has quick feet and uses them to get into position, he wants to be close and then slipping out to Cuadras's right, going up the middle to the body when he's in front of his man, with enough regularity that he shocks Cuadras with a 1-2-3 up the middle. Also important: Cuadras is hitting Rodriguez to no effect. Rodriguez is sticking to his plan. In the third, Rodriguez takes total control of his more experienced opponent. He lands a heleacious right uppercut on Cuadras on 2:35 remaining, he was warned, but he didn't take the warning, he tried to tuck up and hit back and he got hit with the exact same punch and set on his behind (he took the step outside that I was talking about earlier to get there). My favourite thing about this KD: what a grown up Rodriguez looked applying pressure to Cuadras after it. He didn't rush, he kept doing what he was doing before the knockout which was more than good enough! Cuadras did box back in the final minute, that's how long it took him to recover.

    Cuadras clearly lost the fourth but finished it very aggressively; he appeared more thoughtful in the fifth and married to that volume I thought his narrow body-attack just about edged things for him. Rodriguez looked almost unboxable in the sixth; best round of his career. Angles and movement, fluid punces. Cudaras tries to keep his distance in the seventh, a tleast a bit, throw a one-two down the middle, hit around the corners and I thought he got it, a really special round for him to win if i'm honest, it looked like Rodirguez was just going to role right over him, but he did the work at distance, and then left-handed work inside (uppercut and hook to the body). I think he just hypnotised Rodriguez a little bit with a mix of styles he wasn't necessarily expecting after that tough sixth, but he may have rested, I couldn't decide. Anyway, despite Rodriguez having far and away thei bigger moments, this makes it 4-3 to me after seven, so even with the additional point, it's closing up. The seventh feels huge and both men seemed to treat it as such, Rodriguez bringing his pressure, but being careful not to scrap too much inside, pivoting, out-speeding his man two-handed. Another very mature performance another round banked, a crucial one.

    In fact, I didn't score another round for Cuadras. The twelfth is debatable but that's how I see it. This is a great arrival for a fighter, Rodriguez is special. I had almost forgotten how much fun it was to watch Cuadras box too, wide decision but a lot of hotly contested minutes, very good.

    Cuadras:1,5,7,
    Rodriguez:2,3*,4,6,8,9,10,11,12.
    *Cuadras down

    117-110 Rodriguez
    Official: 117-110 x2 and 115-112.
     
  8. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,384
    12,743
    Mar 2, 2006
    Rodriguez is one of the few fighters today whom I really like and follow. Well done.
     
  9. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    113,044
    48,170
    Mar 21, 2007
    You'll be rooting for him this weekend then?
     
    scartissue and Jel like this.
  10. Jel

    Jel Obsessive list maker Full Member

    7,834
    13,128
    Oct 20, 2017
    I’ll be rooting for Estrada but what a cracking matchup it is.
     
    George Crowcroft and McGrain like this.
  11. Dorrian_Grey

    Dorrian_Grey It came to me in a dream Full Member

    2,891
    5,019
    Apr 20, 2024
    I scored the fight for Chocolatito personally but don't disagree with your assessment of it at all. Chocolatito and his team say they use the 1st round to strategise and get a feel for how they'll approach an opponent. And while Choc does mostly scout Estrada in the 1st, he also is taking Estrada's jab away. He gets under his jab, slips the jab, moves laterally to hinder Estrada's ability to throw it, and counters the jab once or twice in the 1st iirc. Choc and his team rightly assessed that the bulk of Estrada's offence is set up by his jab, so worked to undermine it throughout all 3 fights. I love all 3 fights though and Estrada fought well in all.
     
    themaster458 likes this.
  12. scartissue

    scartissue Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,384
    12,743
    Mar 2, 2006
    Oh, yeaaahh!!
     
  13. Dorrian_Grey

    Dorrian_Grey It came to me in a dream Full Member

    2,891
    5,019
    Apr 20, 2024
    Oleksandr Usyk vs Murat Gassiev for the undisputed cruiserweight titles:
    Usyk vs Gassiev:
    1. 10-9 Usyk. Usyk works beautifully behind the jab and confuses Gassiev with his movement.
    2. 10-9 Usyk. Gassiev lands some good shots here and there but Usyk gets the better of the round and controls the action.
    3. 10-9 Usyk. Gassiev is more aggressive this round and backs up Usyk at points but largely fails to land clean and when he does, he’s met by a crisp counter.
    4. 10-10. Both men put in a lot of good work. I thought Usyk might have had the better of the round but Gassiev landed a big right hand to close the round.
    5. 10-9 Usyk. Dominant round for the Ukrainian. Arguably a 10-8.
    6. 10-9 Usyk. The first half of the round was close arguably belonged to Gassiev. Then Usyk tattoos him with combinations for the rest of the round.
    7. 10-9 Gassiev. Gassiev lands some heavy shots and is the aggressor. There’s not a lot in this round and it could probably be given to Usyk but Gassiev landed the cleaner and more effective punches.
    8. 10-9 Usyk. Usyk boxed excellently and dominated this round.
    9. 10-9 Usyk. Closer round but one still belonging to the man from Crimea. First time I noticed Steven Seagal in the crowd too lol.
    10. 10-8 Usyk. Gassiev was completely outclassed here, he landed maybe 3 meaningful clean punches to Usyk’s two dozen or so clean punches and combinations.
    11. 10-8 Usyk. Man is Usyk good. He boxed Gassiev’s ears off and the Russian had no reply.
    12. 10-8 Usyk. Gassiev had no clue what to do anymore and Usyk just landed at will. Thorough domination.
      Total: 119-107 Usyk
      Usyk is a deeply special caliber of fighter. He fights a fellow unified world champion and top level fighter in his own backyard and utterly dismantles him to the point of farce. Those last 3 rounds were some of the most one-sided rounds I think I’ve seen in a long time in a fight between two champions. This was a truly virtuoso performance from Usyk, The Cat is just so endlessly skilled and intelligent. I tell ya, this Oleksandr guy is really something.
      This content is protected
     
    Last edited: Jun 25, 2024
    OddR and Fireman Fred like this.
  14. Dorrian_Grey

    Dorrian_Grey It came to me in a dream Full Member

    2,891
    5,019
    Apr 20, 2024
    Manny Pacquiao vs Oscar De La Hoya:
    Pacquiao vs ODLH:
    1. 10-9 Pac. Close round but Pac lands more and lands the better shots despite being backed up for the most part.
    2. 10-9 Pac. Manny outlands ODLH and slips most of Oscar’s best punches.
    3. 10-9 Pac. Closer round but Pac still got the better of it.
    4. 10-9 Pac. Another close round but Pac still gets the best of it and his combination punching, counters, and head movement are all top notch.
    5. 10-9 Pac. Clear round for the Filipino.
    6. 10-9 Pac. The round begins with some good exchanges, the pace lulls then the pair start trading again to close the round. Pac lands the better shots though.
    7. 10-8 Pac. Oscar is pressured and tattooed around the ring, beaten from pillar to post by the man from the Philippines. Pure willpower kept him standing under the pressure of the barrage he took in this round.
    8. 10-9 Pac. The closest and quietest round of the fight until Pac finishes strongly with clean combinations to Oscar’s head and body who is rocked badly in the closing seconds of the round. The fight is stopped by Oscar’s corner.
    Total score: 80-71 Pac.
    Manny Pacquiao is extraordinary. Plain and simple. No other fighter in the history of the sport has come close to the monumental accomplishments of this Filipino dynamo. In fact, this fight was against the one man who comes closest to Manny in terms of multi-weight achievements. A lot of folk make a lot of noise about how old Oscar was and how drained he was but I don’t wanna get into that and my objections to these arguments or their use in diminishing this win for Pacquiao. The fact of the matter is that Pacquiao looked unstoppable in this fight, he looks like a force of nature, the fluidity of his coordination, his speed, his limitless stamina, and the way he simply runs through someone of the class of De La Hoya are all simply remarkable in this fight. His hand-speed, his foot-speed, his gas tank, his combinations, his counters, his head movement and defence, his sheer will to win are all demonstrated so clearly in this fight. Manny Pacquiao was one of the greatest to have ever laced and if you want proof just watch the guy in action.
    This content is protected
     
  15. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    23,456
    26,763
    Jun 26, 2009
    Muhammad Ali vs. Jerry Quarry I, on Oct. 26, 1970, at Municipal Auditorium in Atlanta, scheduled for 15 rounds at heavyweight.

    Ali, 29-0, is 28 years old and hasn’t fought in 3 1/2 years due to his exile for refusing induction into the U.S. military. The myth is that Ali was allowed to fight because of the Supreme Court decision in his case regarding the draft situation, but that ruling came later — a Georgia senator was able to work behind the scenes to get Muhammad licensed to fight in Atlanta and the fight was made. Muhammad weighed 213 1/2.

    Quarry, 34-4-4, is rated No. 1 by Ring magazine and No. 3 by the WBA. He weighs 197 1/2. He’s won four in a row since losing to George Chuvalo and 11 of his last 13, with his other loss coming to Joe Frazier.

    I’ll use the round system here as was used in the fight at the time.

    1. Ali: Muhammad comes out jabbing and finds the mark with some regularity. Mixes in a few right leads, a couple of hooks and one short flurry. He also shows signs of rust, missing several punches. Quarry patiently stalks and is looking for the left hook but mostly either misses or has it blocked by Ali’s right hand.

    2. Ali: More of the same, with another flurry and gliding with ease around the ring, even backing Jerry up a few times when he pounces. The jab is heavier than in the first round and is reddening the area around Quarry’s right eye. Jerry lands one really good right to the body but that’s about the only effective punch.

    3. Ali: The pattern continues until Ali lands a right that badly busts Quarry open above the left eye. He bleeds a lot in the final minute of the round and Muhammad zeroes in on it and becomes emboldened as he looks for the stoppage. Quarry lasts but he’s getting chewed up.

    The fight is stopped between rounds due to the cut. Jerry hops around in anger for a bit, then goes over to congratulate Ali and his corner and concedes that it’s over with.

    Quarry shows his sportsmanship by making it clear after the fight that the cut was caused by a punch, not a butt (their heads really never came close to clashing that I saw) lest someone try to spin it that way. Ali reciprocates the respect by saying it might have gone 10 rounds had the cut not occurred. Good on both of them.

    My card agrees with all three official cards in a 3-0 verdict for Ali. Really no way to score it otherwise.

    This content is protected
     
    Fireman Fred likes this.