If the ranking rules were as follows: 1) You can only go up in the rankings by beating someone ranked above you, in which case you take their place and everyone in between moves down by 1 place. 2) Fighters are removed from the published rankings after 2 years of inactivity, but will be reinstated if they fight within 5 years. 3) Fighters are removes from the rankings altogether after 5 years of inactivity Then I believe the current Heavyweight rankings would be as follows: 1) Oleksandr Usyk 2) Tyson Fury 3) Anthony Joshua 4) Andy Ruiz Jr 5) Dillian Whyte 6) Joseph Parker 7) Zhilei Zhang 8) Deontay Wilder 9) Robert Helenius 10) Ali Eren Demirezen 11) Kacper Meyna 12) Adam Kownacki 13) Luis Ortiz 14) Jared Anderson 15) Charles Martin 16) Joe Joyce 17) Derek Chisora 18) Lawrence Okolie 19) Lukasz Rozanski 20) Otto Wallin
This is based on my full database of fights, so goes back in some form to the 1800s. Not fully complete obviously, and there may be mistakes, but it goes back far enough to make the current rankings fairly solid.
Who knew Kownacki was such a player in the division! Helenius #9, Demirezen #10, and Meyna #11 But I like it. Really interesting approach Have you got a script so you can punch in a date and pull out the top 20?
May 2009 would be interesting. Haye had moved up from Cruiserweight the year before, but had yet to face Valuev. Who was the top brother? Was Byrd still highly regarded? Top 3 of Wlad, Povetkin, Byrd?
The Kownacki effect is a problem, when a poor fighter gets a good win followed by a string of losses it allows some pretty mediocre fighters to get a ranking. A bad example was when Sedreck Fields beat Shannon Briggs, then lost to every other Heavyweight boxer in the world.
At the end of May 2009, the lineal rankings were as follows: 1) Wladimir Klitschko 2) Alexander Povetkin 3) Chris Byrd 4) Vitali Klitschko 5) Eddie Chambers 6) Samuel Peter 7) James Toney 8) Ruslan Chagaev 9) Nikolay Valuev 10) Larry Donald 11) Sultan Ibragimov 12) Evander Holyfield 13) John Ruiz 14) Oleg Maskaev 15) Hasim Rahman 16) Joseph Chingangu 17) Osborn Machimana 18) Corrie Sanders 19) Shannon Briggs 20) Siarhei Liakhovich
Joyce beat Parker (#13), and became the #13 ranked Heavyweight. When Parker beat Wilder (#7), he jumped up the rankings, but Joyce stayed where he was. This system doesn't look back in time at previous losses, it just works on each fight individually.