If Crawford beats Canelo he is the P4P Goat

I think hed be ahead of Mayweather and Pacquiao based on weight classes and the way he dominated his opponents. I agree that strictly resume wise based off names it wouldnt be but I dont only go off of names

 

Spence was definitely great

Revisionist history saying otherwise.

 

I didnt say he would have the best resume of all time

Being the goat isnt only about resume

 

No Mccalums resume is not above Terence Crawford. McCallum was a great fighter and an ATG 154 pounder but he did not separate himself from his opposition the way Crawford did.

Yes Crawfords resume is thin (due to unfortunate circumstances) but hes dominated and exceeded expectations time and time again

Resume isn't everything. Roy Jones Jr is considered to be an ATG and by some people, even the best ever (not me) and he didnt have the deepest most thorough resume.

 

It is the truth
A lot of these older fighters were able to rack up wins, titles and many Kos because of the times they were in. Boxers fight twice a year now (sometimes once) and the opposition is stronger on average. This is reality

 

I didnt say ATG and Mayweather has no wins over any ATG in their primes and is considered by many as the goat

Same as Roy Jones (no James Toney is not an ATG and Bernard Hopkins was not in prime)

How many wins does Pacquiao have vs all time greats (no Morales, Marquez and Barrera arent all time great. Just in era greats)

Pernell Whitaker also has none

Even Sugar Ray Leonards wins over Duran (came at WW when Durans best weight was Lightweight), Hagler (past prime), Hearns (arguably green and peaked at 154 not 147) werent ATG in their primes.

This criteria is bogus and only used to discredit current fighters

 

I never said best resume in history

Please tell me who has better timing than Terence Crawford

As a hardcore boxing fan I would love to see it