BoxRec all time P4P ranking.

51 Trinidad, too high
52. Patterson, laugably high
53. Lew Tendler, way too high
54. Pernell Whitaker, way too low
55. Rocky Kansas, way too high
56. Andre Ward, way too high
57. Rocky Marciano, no objections
58. Gustav Scholz, whoever put him there is on the spectrum
59. Jack Caroll, literally who ?
60. Willie Pep, laughably low.
61. Randy Turpin, way too high
62. Tommy Gibbons, no objections
63. Sammy Mandell, I'm fine with
64. Kostya Tzyu, way too high
65. Bobo Olson, way too high
66. Dick Tiger, no objections
67. Freddie Dawson, way too high but I like how niche a choice he is
68. Wladimir Klitschko, should be lower
69. Marcel Cerdan, should be way lowe
70. Ismael Laguna, way too high
71. Kid Gavilan, laughably low
72. Juan Manuel Marquez, should be a bit lower
73. Bruno Arcari, who ?
74. Lou Ambers, no objections
75. Packey McFarland, laughably low
76. Gene Fullmer. probably too high
77. Tommy Loughran, way too low
78. Freddie Welsh, no objections
79. Gervonta Davis, why is a prospect on the list ?
80. Jake LaMotta, no objections with
81. Johnny Kilbane, no objections with I think
82. Jack Dempsey, should be lower
83. Jack Kid Berg, I think I'm fine with
84. Lockport Jimmy Duffy, should be lower
85. Nino Benvenuti, laughably high
86. Louis Kid Kaplan, too high
87. Evander Holyfield, way too low
88. Khaosai Galaxy, way too high
89. Jimmy Bivins, way too low
90. Vicente Saldivar, way too low
91. Marco Antonio Barrera, no objections
92. Larry Holmes, I'm fine with
93. Carl Froch, way too high
94. Vitali Klitschko, laughably high
95. Ruben Olivares, laughably low
96. Jeff Smith, too high
97. Sammy Angott, I think could be higher
98. Lloyd Marshall, should be higher
99. Freddie Miller, should be higher
100. Sam Langford, offensively low

 

SRL would run you out of the ring so fast you wouldn't have time to poop yourself.

 

I stopped reading it after seeing May Jr. at #3

 

What is the criteria for this list?

 

The first rule of boxing is to defend yourself.

 

I try now and then but I run into too many problems.

 

Willie pep number 60 man this list is garbage.

 

That cowardly ***** wouldn't do ****.

 

So you'd beat Ray Leonard in his prime?

 

The boxrec one, as noted, is created by an algorithm.

But to fairly criticize it, I think anyone should list their own 50 or 100.

Easiest (and laziest) thing in the world is to do nothing, look at something someone else does and say ‘no, I don’t like it.’ Well, do it better. Your own list may not stand up to scrutiny by others.

 

With ease.