Were does Vitali Kiltschko rank among all time heavyweights?

Top 15 for me

 

But top 20 for 16-17th places it's okay too

 

I really liked Vitali but I don't know if I can put him in the top 15. He won 15 times in matches with the world title at stake, beating good and excellent boxers, he lacks the victory against a champion. He was unlucky to fight little because of injuries and also not to have a rematch with Lewis. I would definitely put him in the top 20 heavyweights of all time.

 

Vitali might be the most overrated heavyweight of all time. His resume is shyte and he didn't beat anyone of significance, to be viewed as some kind of a H2H monster. Top 30 is my pick, but I wouldn't argue if someone put him in Top 20. People say Wlad was boring, but try to watch most of Vitali's fights...

 

Top 15 for me beat some good but not great boxers dominated all of them and even his losses were fights he was up where he got a bit unlucky but definitely doesn't have his brothers resume

 

He was still a very good boxer with a great potential, but injuries heavily impacted his career, so I can't rate him off "what would have happened if he wasn't getting injured that much and took harder, more riskier fights".

 

Top 30ish for achievements; top 10-15ish Head-to-Head.

 

Dubios already has a pair of wins that are much better than Vitalis two best wins.

 

After thinking a bit more about, Top 20 seems the most accurate.

 

I voted top 15 by accident because I read it as if it was Wlad.
Vitali is top 20.

 

I find him very difficult to rank.

His win resume is nowhere near the 20th best in HW history, but his dominance hints at a fighter easily amongst the best 20 ever.

For whatever it's worth, #20 is where he washed up on my list when I completed my analysis a few years ago.

 

H2H, top 5.
Greatness, outside the top 10.

 

What's his best win exactly? Old Sanders? He honestly shouldn't be ranked any higher than a guy like Fury. Maybe 25-35 range.