Watering down punching mechanics and the nature of power to quoting pounds is much more of a leap in logic or outright willing blindness than presuming Foreman would be able to handle Joshua's and Dubois' power. The very same Foreman who: a) was comfortably taking shots from Frazier b) after a long layoff, devastating loss, and changed trainer and approach prevailed in a war against Lyle who just stopped Shavers. He literally hit the canvas head-first and got up as if he just took a nap. The so-called super heavyweight chins of say Fury, Joshua, Klitschko, or with all due respect Lewis, would not hold up to the challenge. c) Later took shots from Cooney who is a notoriously hard and explosive hitter even at the downturn of his career. d) Not to mention the absolute punching-bag like combinations Holyfield couldn't dent him with. Size and pounds influence power, but it's much more of a complex topic and countless times throughout the history big men couldn't punch with some excellent small punchers, and couldn't take a punch like their fellow tank-like smaller boxers could (Mercer, Chuvalo, Tua, McCall to name few who would be branded small compared to the super heavyweight standard.) Even recently Wilder was scoring his most devastating knockouts at 210-230 range, visibly slowing down and struggling when attempting to bulk. You try to brush aside fighters based solely on either pounds or inches and some of the history's finest will show up to prove you wrong. Those are exceptions and not the rule, but we are in most cases debating the exceptional fighters here, regardless of the occasional slander. Lyle was a murderous puncher. Shavers said so. Foreman said so. Bugner said his fight with him nearly killed him and he was pissing blood from the body shots if I remember correctly. Mean puncher.
Don't forget Shannon Briggs as well. Briggs was a massive puncher and he couldn't even move Foreman. Foreman is as durable as anyone that has fought in the heavyweight division.
Ali’s right hand was textbook basically one of the only conventional things Ali consistently did was throw and use his right hand properly.
Yep. This isn't even close. Ali was a borderline banger before the hand issues came up. Watch how opponents reacted to his right. They did NOT like it. I'll give an honorable mention to Holmes for having the hardest jab among the three. Although then again, when Usyk goes for those spear jabs, they look real stiff. Holmes did have a better right uppercut than either man. Had a nice right hook too.
Foreman proved his durability against the men he faced, but the key mistake you're making is that you are assuming that durability is a magical quality that is independent of physics, it isn't. A 250lb man carries more kinetic energy into a collision than a 220lb man. That's not watering down mechanics, that's the reality of force. The question isn't whether Foreman was tough. The question is whether his toughness, proven mostly against smaller men, would hold up to the force generated by athletes 30-40 pounds heavier when guys like Young were able to rock him. By dismissing the weight difference, you're essentially arguing against the very reason weight classes exist which It's an unprovable leap of faith on your part.
this is such a dishonest argument. Foreman stood up to the power of Cooney, Morrison, Briggs etc. and we are supposed to pretend that because he had one knockdown that resulted more from exhaustion vs Young that he somehow had a mediocre chin. Lyle was the same weight as Wilder who dropped the super heavyweight Fury twice. Your arguments have been disproven already. The majority of the hardest hitters in heavyweight history weighed between 210-225 lbs at their peak including Wilder. Bigger heavyweights are not more durable nor do they punch any harder. There is nothing impressive about rocking Fury considering how many times he has been rocked before. Fury, Joshua and Dubois are not even in the same league durability wise as Ali, Holmes, Foreman etc. Its not even a debate dude. I have no problem admitting when i am wrong. Yet you and others on this thread keep repeating the same false disproven arguments over and over again.
I would also give Ali the edge in terms of the lead hook. Ali had a very good left hook. Holmes had the best uppercut of the bunch.
Pretty words to describe force = mass × acceleration. Unfortunately punching mechanics are far more complex than that and that's excluding accuracy and all that. Connecting and compounding force through kinetic chains, general athleticism and explosiveness, nervous system engagement (and visualization and 'intentions' play a role as well), and skeletal structure (the so-called heavy hands), and the entire other part in an umbrella term of leverage—accuracy, delivery (snap etc.), angles, target selection. Who cares if Foreman didn't take shots from 300 lbs Dustin Nichols. He took shots from men who are still considered some of the hardest punchers ever (Lyle, Cooney, Briggs mentioned brilliantly by another poster.) Young dropping exhausted and soon to be nearly dying from heat exhaustion in a tropical climate Foreman means nothing. EDIT: Pounds are a good, healthy, and well-meaning division of the sport ensuring health and providing opportunity to move up to seek greatness for exceptional individuals. We discuss exceptional on daily basis. No hiding behind the f=ma and x lbs skirt.