Just found out that Toney was calling out Tyson after he KO'ed Holyfield in October 03 weighing a svelte 217. Tyson had just KO'ed Ettiene in 1 round earlier that year weighing in the same ballpark at 225. Who wins it early 2004? Bonus: Manny Pacquiao vs In-Jin Chi will be featured on the undercard
Tyson was finished in 2004, after beating Etienne the year before, and would lose his last three fights badly. So, I'd say Toney would win on points or a late stoppage. In the undercard, Pacman would dominate In Jin Chi and winning on points.
Honestly... this might be crazy but the version Holyfield beat might lose to a cruiserweight version of Toney, I watch the inside exchanges / negotiating and I know KNOW Toney had the chin to survive and skills like MT hadn't ever seen... it'd be a great bout regardless, as for this fight discussed yeah JT would stop him.
After 1997, Tyson doesn't stand much of a chance against the Toney who beat Evander Holyfield. Toney tko
Toney is 2003-2005 was a good heavyweight, enjoyed a good spell there. He'd defeat Tyson in 2004, stoppage.