Do you agree with Boxrecs all time pfp list ?

Not sure if Mayweather warrants being above Ali...

 

No ****ing way

 

Not even read the list and disagree with it.

 

SRL @ 40 on list so it's bs to me.
ps Calzaghe res is just as good Floyd Mayweather Jr @ 3rd.

 

Young Corbett III at 25 over SRL, Lennox Lewis, Barney Ross?

Surely they used an AI algorithm to come up with such nonsense.

 

No.

Greb , SRR, Armstrong, Benny Leonard I'm fine with.. & Mclarnin I'd have top 15/20.. but I'd have (along with the 4 mentioned above) Langford, Charles, Fitz, Ross, Walker & Moore/Tunney as my top 10. There are some good mentions there and fighters that don't get enough credit such as the aforementioned Mclarnin & Young Corbett III who was is one of THE great southpaws... but Floyd at 3? Nah..

 

Ross is a close one, but I'd edge Ross.. LL? yes.. Corbett is greater than Lennox IMO.. SRL? I'd probably have Leonard higher... YC III was an exceptional fighter tho... He jumped up to MW from WW & beat Conn, Walker , Apostoli & Lesnevich .. that's an insane set of wins.. let alone his WW work where he beat great fighters like Ceferino Garcia, Jack Thompson & Jackie Fields... all twice! There's multiple HOFers there.. & he was just 5'7... a natural WW .. 155 fights, 12 losses... come on.. that's an exceptional career. Better than Lewis' who more often than not had a size advantage and fought fighters past their best. YC is without doubt a top 30 for me...

 

Fine but higher than SRL?

 

To be honest any list of this nature will drive people nuts.

 

Canelo is at 15 so no.

 

Jimmy Wilde @ # 249 ?

 

I don't think it's the worst list but I don't agree with all of it

 

It's not the worst P4P list, but there are plenty of inconsistencies and it should not be taken as gospel.

 

Salvador Sanchez at 149 absolute shite