Who is better P4P? Usyk or Mayweather?

7 years later Usyk has now proven he is on the same level as Mayweather.

 

7 years later. I believe Usyk is better P4P

 

Well Usyk. By far. ESPECIALLY since you used the word FIGHTER. Someone that beats all the world class boxers in their own backyards then takes a break from the sport to fight in his country in the war is the epitome of fighter.

How many belts has mayweather won in opponents backyards with actual neutral judges??? And if US were invaded how many actually think he would have to be persuaded to leave the front lines to go resume boxing to represent his country???

 

It's still Mayweather nothing has changed.

World title wins.

Mayweather has won twice as many world title fights.

Mayweather at 26.

Usyk at 13.

Wins vs top 10 P4P fighters.

Mayweather beat 6 or 7 ? Top 10 P4P fighters.

Usyk has beaten 0.

Resume

Mayweather has a better resume.

Mayweathers best wins

Pacquiao
ODLH
Canelo
JMM
Hatton
Cotto
Corrales
Castillo x2
Mosley
Maidana x2
G.Hernandez
Gatti
Judah
Berto
Ortiz
Guerrero
Manfredy


Usyk's best wins

Fury x2
Joshua x2
Dubois x2
Chisora
Briedis
Gassiev
Hunter
Bellew
Glowacki
Huck

It's Mayweather by a considerable margin people just don't like Mayweather which is fine he's not the most likeable person but they let that cloud their judgement.

 

P4P is fiction. Little man syndrome.

 

@Dynamicpuncher I like many have Usyk over Mayweather.

You sound really sensitive over the subject.

But as the poll results clearly show it's definitely not a foregone conclusion like you're desperately trying to claim.

Whilst deliberately ignoring facts such as Usyk turning pro about 7 years older than Floyd and fighting in a division where they usually don't ever be in p4p lists . And Usyk being undisputed in two divisions, and Mayweather being undisputed in zero. Usyk winning a world title in just his 10th fight, Mayweather was in his 17th fight. And so on.

 

Mayweather. Ask Usyk. Bet he agrees.

 

The term is a little skeptical but I thought Greb was your P4P GOAT?

 

I agree Mayweather's achievements/wins are still better but I think the argument of Uysk fighting as a B side and overcoming such huge physical disadvantages when he wasn't expected to does make it closer than the above suggests.

 

But on the flip side Mayweather has fought considerably more fighters who are considered great or hall of fame worthy.

And I think in general the lower weightclasses have more talented skillful fighters on average.

So whilst Usyk's achievements for beating good skilled big men is to be admired.

I still think Mayweathers overall quality of opposition is considerably better IMO.

 

Since when has undisputed mattered? Floyd was universally considered the best at 130, 135, 147. He beat more ranked opponents at 130 than Usyk did at cruiserweight and more at 147 than Usyk did at heavyweight.

 

The guy who has won more titles, jumped more weight classes, beaten more HOF fighters, and has twice as much fights. I'm a bigger fan of Usyk over Mayweather but this is a huge no brainer. Mayweather and quite clearly.

 

Usyk's resume is all killer no filler. Floyds was all done carefully by the watch.

Of course Usyk's not going to have as many wins on paper as your American heroes who turned pro's as teenagers and fought a bum a month. Usyk turned pro late and went straight for the best fighers and biggest punchers, and beat them all in their backyards. Usyk had cojones we never saw in Floyd.

Anyone who knows boxing, knows how super special Usyk is. He defines greatness in every way. A genius boxer, with the highest Ring IQ possible who's won literally everything there is to win, pro and amateur.

People recently love to try to discredit what Usyk has done. But go back in their post history and look what they were saying years ago, it's highly likely they were saying Usyk has no chance at Heavyweight, that he was too small for heavyweight, that he'd have no chance against Joshua and Fury.