Your Top 5 p4p Fighters

1. Sugar Ray Leonard, best resume in history. Wins over Duran, Hearns and Hagler. Probably the best combination of talent, athleticism, fight IQ and mentality ever.

2. Muhammad Ali, best heavyweight resume by a long shot. Lison, Patterson, Foreman, Frazier, Norton, as well as a truly elite prime 1965-1967, with speed never seen before or since at heavyweight, he could easily have been #1 if he never lost those three years of his prime.

3. Roy Jones, best H2H boxer of all time. Not just wins over Hopkins and Toney but complete shutouts. Never even looked mortal in his prime. Only thing keeping him from #1 is that his resume is a bit light outside of those two.

4. Floyd Mayweather. Absolutely elite prime at 130 and 135. In addition his resume is absolutely stacked with champions, yes, a lot of them weren't at their absolute best but that doesn't make them free wins. The sheer variety of styles he faced while barely ever looking beatable is crazy.

5. Is where I think there's a lot of guys who have great arguments. Carlos Monzon's resume is stacked, Manny Pacquiao of course with titles in eight weight classes, Pernell Whitaker made multiple other ATGs look absolutely foolish. I wouldn't be angry at anyone in this spot, but I feel like the four above guys are a comfortable tier ahead of any of them.

Just FYI I don't know jack about boxing pre circa 1965 so if you want to tell me some guy with only grainy black and white footage would destroy Ray Leonard, I guess I can't argue with that.

 

#01: Harry Greb
#02: Sugar Ray Robinson
#03: Henry Armstrong
#04: Sam Langford
#05: Ezzard Charles

I can see a different order but not different names.

 

bro DOES NOT know ball

 

This is my list but with Charles at 3 instead of Hank

 

SRR
Greb
Langford
Armstrong
Charles

 

My top 10:

Greb
SRR
Langford
Armstrong
Charles
Fitz
Walker
Pep
Ross
Moore/Tunney

 

1 : Ray Robinson
2 : Harry Greb
3 : Henry Armstrong
4 : Roberto Duran
5 : Ezzard Charles

 

Langford, Greb, Charles, Robinson, Armstrong

 

My top 3 is the same as yours

 

1. Harry Greb
2. Sam Langford
3. Willie Pep
4. Roberto Duran
5. Ray Robinson

 

SRR , Duran , Mayweather , Ali , Crawford.

 

Hi Buddy.
My list would look very similar, with Greb at 1, maybe I would swop Ross for Duran, that apart a good list, especially like Walker being included, not many do, well done.
stay safe buddy, chat soon.
Mike.

 

those five not sure on order