Joe Calzaghe or Robin Ried"? Who won?

Was the closest Calzaghe came to a loss and a lot of fans think Reid should have got the nod.
Who do you think won?

 

Me and some mates watched this live on tv. At the time I thought Reid nicked it I will have to watch it back. It was very close and there should have been a rematch.

 

Exactly what I thought, Reid couldn’t miss with his right. Pity there wasn’t a rematch.

 

Reid.
Close enough fight but I think I had it to Reid by two rounds at the time.
Such a shame they didn't do it again.

 

Think Reid. I know Joe broke his hand clean in the 3rd or 4th but still.

 

Calzaghe by a smidge

 

Close fight but Reid came on strong in the second half, don't get how the judges got it 116-111 either way. Shame he got stiffed again in Germany. If had beaten Lacy the rematch would have been huge. Liked Robin back in the day he was a class act.