Rank these fighters in order (P4P)

Hearns
RJJ
Hagler
Lewis
Hopkins



...



Canelo

 

Hagler
Hearns
Jones
Hopkins
Alvarez
Lewis

 

Marvin Hagler
Roy Jones Jr
Thomas Hearns
Canelo Alvarez
Bernard Hopkins (expert on dirty tactics)
Lennox Lewis (just big with long arms, not great P4P)

 

For me this is different based on Achievements and Resume vs H2H/Eyetest/Skills etc

P4P Achievements & Resume

1. Roy Jones Jr (achievement wise you can't deny Roy)
2. Tommy Hearns
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Canelo Alvarez
5. Lennon Lewis (single weight)
6. Marvin Hagler (single weight)

Skills/H2H/Eyetest/Non-Achievements

1. Marvin Hagler (although he never won anywhere else, think prime Hagler P4P is best on the list
2. Roy Jones Jr - at his peak he was nearly untouchable (think Hagler beats him though due to intangibles)
3. Lennox Lewis
4. Tommy Hearns
5. Bernard Hopkins (made his name at 160lb beating smaller guys mostly)
6. Canelo Alvarez

 

Jones
Hagler
Hearns
Lewis
Hopkins
Canelo

 

@Greg Price99

 

RJJ
Hagler
Hearns/Hopkins
Lewis
Canelo

Pretty comfortable with the order aside from Hearns/Hopkins 3rd and 4th. I'd need to spend time comparing the two in detail to be confident which should be higher.

 

Marvin Hagler
Thomas Hearns
Roy Jones Jr
Lennox Lewis
Bernard Hopkins

Deleted Canelo because he's a ginger midget who lost to a 40 year old flyweight.

 

Jones Jr.
Hagler
Hopkins
Hearns
Lewis
Canelo (Canelo has a better resume/achievements than Lewis but I think Lewis was more skilled p4p)

 

This list is the same as mine.

 

Jones Jr.
Hagler
Hearns
Lewis
Alvarez
Hopkins


I'm no Canelo fan and think he's overrated, but it's unfair to put him in with retired legends.

 

Resume and Achievements:

1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. Thomas Hearns
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Lennox Lewis
5. Marvin Hagler
6. Canelo Alvarez (fought in more weight classes but has weaker wins than the rest. GGG was robbed.)

H2H and Skills:

1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. Marvin Hagler
3. Lennox Lewis (arguably the best heavyweight of all time H2H)
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Thomas Hearns
6. Canelo Alvarez

Personal Favorites:

1. Thomas Hearns
2. Lennox Lewis
3. Marvin Hagler
4. Roy Jones Jr.
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Canelo Alvarez

 

1- Hagler
2- Thomas Hearns
3- Lennox Lewis
4- Roy Jones Jr
5- Bernard Hopkins
------------------------
6- Canelo

 

In my p4p ranking this is the order

Jones
Hearns
Hopkins
Hagler
Lewis
Canelo

I consider them all ATG except Canelo (a great of his era).