Who is greater P4P Floyd Mayweather or Archie Moore?

Came to mind.

 

Moore pretty clearly.

Simply beat the better fighters, and is one of the few who who clearly surpass Mayweather in terms of longevity. He's got more losses, but he's also got like 10 wins that are better than any of Floyd's outside of Pac. Plus like, something like 30-40 more wins over rated opposition than Floyd does. His depth is insane.

Having the all time KO record (I don't recognise that Billy Bird mfer) doesn't hurt either.

 

Nothing much in it for me,this is how i have them in my atg list
13 - Mayweather
15 - Moore

 

Moore

 

Moore is clearly greater and Floyd is slightly better.

 

I knew flip a coin would be handy.

 

Comparable resumes would you say?

 

Mayweather. He was the top dog of a decade and a half span. Mayweather beat Canelo, but Moore didn’t beat Marciano.

 

Archie Moore. He didn't cherry pick anything.

 

So maybe Moore's losses evening it out or something?

 

May certainly had a better curated career.

 

Mayweather is levels above Moore, not close. Anyone want to try and argue a skillset Moore had over Mayweather?

Mayweather would have probably shut out the Burley who dominated Moore too. What happened when Moore fought elite opponents in Burley, Charles and Marciano?

The only argument for Moore over Mayweather is he may have beat Floyd with 30-40lb on him. That's believable. Otherwise P4P Moore is levels below

 

I nearly got confused to what you meant. lol