Rank Ray Leonard Thomas Hearns Floyd Mayweather Terence Crawford

Can’t rate Crawford don’t know enough about him. Seems like he’s beating good fighters.

P4P
Leonard
Mayweather
Hearns

H2H
Leonard
Hearns
Mayweather

 

I’m gonna go with yes.

 

Exactly who?

 

At least five guys.

 

Resume:

Leonard
Hearns
Mayweather
Crawford

H2H

Leonard
Hearns
Crawford
Mayweather

 

Historically on an all time ranking list I would go Leonard, Mayweather, Hearns, Crawford.

H2H I would put Floyd lower, as he’s a naturally smaller guy. I’d pick him over Bud at the lower weights, but not when they are at higher divisions. And Hearns is maybe the worst matchup for him at WW.

 

Leonard
Mayweather
Hearns
Crawford

 

In the minority but I like Mayweather for 1st.

 

He is definitely the most skilled P4P out of this group

 

Why not hearns over Floyd? Hearns definitely has the better names and fought in a much tougher era

 

It is close for me but i disagree over better names.Duran aside i think overall Floyd beat a greater number of good fighters

 

Overall
Leonard
Hearns
Mayweather
Crawford

Resume
Mayweather
Hearns
Leonard
Crawford

Best win goes to Leonard, best fights go to Leonard, most charisma, best moneymaker, it is what it is. He had it. But Mayweather had more title fights before he changed his ring name to "Money" than Leonard had in his whole career, and a big chunk of Leonard's time in the game was spent living the celebrity life. Hearns was the mightiest fighter of the bunch and would knock Crawford out, I believe. Mayweather caught a lot of guys post-prime but generally speaking he fought good fighters even accounting for their decline. I think Leonard would also do work against Mayweather. Crawford has been expertly managed and beaten who was in front of him. It's hard to tell how he would do, when he looked very human vs Benavidez, Madrimov and Gamboa. Yes, he won those fights but I wasn't convinced and I still am not. In resume I am torn between ranking Hearns higher for his activity or Leonard higher for his best quality of wins including Hearns. I will go Hearns. On paper Mayweather is incredible, and you have to have a solid knowledge base to deconstruct his legacy. Although I don't mind ranking Hearns or Leonard above him for singular win quality--Mayweather was so great at 130 it's ridiculous.

 

Ray, Terrence Tommy , Floyd at 147 .. at 168 I never saw Ray look like Crawford did but Crawford was fighting a stubby Canelo so who knows

 

I think Hearns has a better resume than Floyd though. Benitez is arguably better than Floyd and his opposition but your position is sound

 

Mayweather
Bud
Leonard - Hearns (tie)