The worst individual scorecards of all-time. Lets hear yours.

Moritas one for Tyson over Douglas
Williams one for Holy over Lewis I

and Miquel Donate who had Azumah Nelson getting the nod over Fenech I 116-112, i had Fenech by a similar score from memory

 

James Toney Dave Tiberi

 

Franco Priami scoring Johnny Tapia vs. Nana Konadu a draw. I kid you not when I say the only arguable round Konadu won was when Frank Cappuccino scored a knockdown against Johnny when he got hit on the the lat/shoulder area in one of the worst knockdown calls of all time.

Blatant example of Don Kingism where Johnny would have been ****ed over if he didn't pitch a shutout.

Willie Pep scoring the first Johnny Famechon vs. Fighting Harada fight for Famechon was another disgrace. Harada won by a good 5 points.

 

The three assholes that scored DLH-Sturm for Oscar also need to be called out. Clearly on the take and imo the worst decision in the last decade (that I have seen in any case).

 

Junior Jones v Orlando Canizales. Scores of 118-111 and 117-111, plus one incredible 109-119. Something is wrong here.

Woller

 

I know Lurie , he was known for talking to friends and drinking whiskey while action was taking place and asking people at ringside what they thought about a round he may have missed.. i have talked to Art while he judged bouts.. He hardly watched most of the rounds..

 

and Miquel Donate who had Azumah Nelson getting the nod over Fenech I 116-112, i had Fenech by a similar score from memory[/quote]

mate...... for the first time since the actual fight, Ive found another with a similar point of view... Yeah, yeah... Fenech was robbed.. blah blah.... not as desicively as the Aussie folk.. (Im Australian), would like it to be read out.

Its almost a point of arguement amongst the wankers at any pub, who continue to claim that Fenech won almost every round..

Yeah.. he won almost every round indeed.. almast won the first..
Almost won the second.....
almost won the third..

The fight was a very close match in the end... Fenech by a couple of rounds... I think a few stupid actions from the early rounds cost him the judges favor in the later rounds..

 

A recent humdinger would be Francisco Mouret's 100-90 score for Julio Cesar Chavez after his life-and-death struggle in the first fight against Matt Vanda.

Whichever judge, possibly Sheila Harmon, that scored 5 drawn rounds (89-87) in Rahman-Tua I...very very lazy.

Robert Grasso having Rahman-Tua II somehow as 116-112 Tua is another outstandingly boneheaded card.

 

Judges and Referee in the Robin Reid v Sven Ottke

 

roy jones jr at the olympics was real bad

 

Aussie folk?

A prominent USA mag among others made it robbery of the year. There was outrage in America. American, Aussie, black or white it WAS a robbery and anyone saying other is either biased or knows jack**** about boxing.

No surprise you class Fenech supporters as wankers. Fenech indeed won a hell of a lot of rounds.

Look, we get it. Fenech (allegedly) has ripped off a few of your pals and you HATE his guts with a passion. It shows. We follow.

So you scored the first three rounds for Nelson then?

Oh rubbish. Post your card, i need a good laugh.

When you win as many rounds as Fenech did against Nelson i find this comment ludicrous to say the least.

 

I gave Nelson 3 of the first 4 rounds - and still had him losing 117-111.

I would like to see flamengo's scorecard for this one.

 

The overall decision and how you see the fight, I agree with. But I can't see him winning 3 or the first 4.

 

How did you carve up the rounds? To me it was fairly evident that Fenech started slow but once he started to roll Nelson never got a look in again.