Fighter of the year

1.Pacman
2.Margarito

 

Co-sign, both of em has done wonders for boxing.. I am really grateful of being around when they are.

 

It's Pacquiao by a distance.

Then maybe Hopkins.

Then Calzaghe.

Then Wlad.

Then Margo.

IMO.

 

PAc
or
JC

 

I personally have Vic Darchinyan as fighter of the year, due to my subjective opinion that he won vs. Gorres, rate Kirilov over David Diaz and the Mijares win is clearly above the shot Oscar (I predicted he will be shot) and the JMM decision, which was a loss for PacMan on my scorecard. Then again: it's a subjective pick, but I scored these fights as any other, so I'm basing my opinion on my cards insted of the judges'.

It's very close and PacMan is there as a deserving candidate (as well as Margarito)... just Darchinyan did so well this year against the odds, I have to go with him. You can count in a bit of 'attention whoring', but it's not about me but about Darchinyan who deserves more attention and credit.

No one even mentions his name anywhere despite his victory was Hopkins-Pavlik and Margarito-Cotto combined: both extemely dominating and a brutal knockout of Mijares, a PROVEN top3 technician P4P.

 

totally agree:good

 

Who did Wlad beat to be placed before Margo, who beat Cintron and Cotto?

Margo has to be second for what he did this year as a wehole not just one fight. Like Hopkins who was great against Pavlik but lost to Calzaghe.

Calzaghe gets credit for the Hopkins win but is was still close and Jones was just not a great win, other than for the name recognition.



1. *******
2. Margie

 

1. Pacquiao
2. Margarito
3. Darchinyan
4. Hatton

Calzaghe isn't even in the top 10.

 

1 Pac
2 Margo
3 Hopkins
4 Vitali: Like it or not to straight back into a title fight, after all those years out and win a HW title, make the guy quit on his stool, is worth a nod (even if it was against Peter).

 

pacquiao just edges out margarito imo

 

1 calzaghe
2 margario (but no complaint with him #1)--Cotto was a very impressive victory, if was for not hopkins fight with palvik, i would of had margarito on top with this victory alone, not counting cintron......
3 pac-man (DLH was shot, very shot, an he was there for the check) So does diaz an marquez warrent a FOY title,,,NO,

 

Calzaghe is fighter of the year.
Pacman is second.
No way is hopkins ahead of calzaghe, He lost to him.

 

hopkins deserves some votes. beat pavlik and lost close decision to calzaghe